Analysis · Resident Evil 5

Resident Evil 5 swaps dread for co-op firefights and stiff aim

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Stunning to look at, stiff to control

Game Informer's Joe Juba and Matt Miller said Resident Evil 5 had the best graphics of any game released so far. Kotaku's Brian Crecente called it one of the most visually stunning games he had played. Juba also made the sharpest complaint about it: because you can't move and shoot at the same time, he said the difficulty felt raised in a "cheap and artificial" way rather than built through tension.

That split between how the game looks and how it handles runs through the reviews, but most critics still came down on the positive side. Official Xbox Magazine's Corey Cohen liked the fast pace, X-Play's Adam Sessler called the graphics exceptional, and Edge described the action as exhilarating and frantic. Game Informer also credited the music and voice acting with bringing the characters to life.

The controls are the real fight

This is an over-the-shoulder third-person shooter with handguns, shotguns, automatic rifles, sniper rifles, grenade launchers and melee attacks. Boss fights lean on quick time events. You can spin 180 degrees to escape a crowd, but as in Resident Evil 4, you have to stand still to fire.

Critics kept coming back to this. 1UP.com's James Mielke found the aiming too slow, missed being able to strafe or hop back from enemies, and disliked that cover only works in certain spots. He still called it "a very fun game." Eurogamer's Kristan Reed thought the quick turn was slow and the inventory awkward to reach.

The inventory itself did get simpler and faster:

  • Each player carries nine items, and a herb takes up as much space as a grenade launcher.
  • Four items can be mapped to the D-pad.
  • Gear swaps happen in real time, without pausing.
  • Weapons can be upgraded from the inventory screen at any time, with no merchant to find.

Built for two players, awkward for one

Resident Evil 5 is the first game in the series designed for two-player co-op. One player is Chris, a former STARS member now with the BSAA. The other is Sheva, a new character. You can play together online or split screen, though each split-screen window is letterboxed, which leaves empty space on both sides. A downed player can only be revived by their partner, so staying close matters.

Solo players get a computer-controlled Sheva. IGN's Ryan Geddes praised parts of her behavior but said she tends to burn through ammo and healing items. That's a real cost in a game where both are limited.

Replay value was a common point of praise. Geddes called it surprisingly high, and GameZone's Louis Bedigian said the game was "worth playing through twice" in a weekend. Finishing the story unlocks the timed Mercenaries mode and the option to play as Sheva. Critics also liked the add-on episodes: GameZone gave "Lost in Nightmares" eight out of 10, and IGN gave "Desperate Escape" seven.

Less survival horror, more action movie

Several reviewers missed the horror. GameRevolution's Chris Hudak called it a "full-on action blockbuster." Crecente said that about halfway through, it stops pretending to be survival horror at all. Reed expected the push toward action fans to upset some longtime players. The game also has fewer puzzles than earlier entries, a linear story, and most character interaction happens in cutscenes.

A setting that still draws criticism

The game's setting caused controversy before release. Its 2007 trailer showed a white protagonist killing black enemies in an African village, and Newsweek's N'Gai Croal said it echoed classic racist imagery. In a 2009 preview, Eurogamer's Dan Whitehead said the game leaned on "dark continent" clichés and that adding Sheva made the problem worse.

Others disagreed. IGN's Hilary Goldstein didn't think it was deliberately racist, though he expected some players would be offended. Anthropologist Glenn Bowman called the accusations "silly" and pointed to an anti-colonial theme. The BBFC reviewed one disputed cutscene and found no racism issue in it. Then, in 2015, researchers Harrer and Pichlmair placed the game within a long history of commodity racism. Critics never settled the question, and it's worth weighing before you buy.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet