Analysis · Resident Evil 6

Resident Evil 6 trades fear for firepower across four uneven campaigns

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for co-op action fans, not horror purists

Resident Evil 6 was made for players who want a loud third-person shooter with a partner at their side. Capcom called it a "dramatic horror", but several critics simply labeled it an action shooter. Metacritic summed up the complaints as a game that was "more generic shooter than distinctive survival horror game." If you come to this series for scarce ammo and slow dread, critics say this entry mostly isn't for you.

For the co-op crowd, the setup is generous. Four interwoven campaigns follow Leon S. Kennedy, Chris Redfield, Jake Muller and Ada Wong. In the first three, you can play as the lead or as their partner: Helena Harper, Piers Nivans or Sherry Birkin. The other character is run by the AI or by a second player, locally or online, and someone can join a solo game online at any time. The game is twice as long as Resident Evil 5, and the extra modes add more on top.

Where it delivers: movement, monsters and scale

The most consistent praise went to how the game moves. You can roll in any direction, run while shooting and slide, and a stamina bar limits melee attacks and instant headshot "quickshots." Hollander Cooper of GamesRadar said the controls had an emphasis on fluidity and movement, and Jose Otero of 1Up.com also called them an improvement. The Escapist liked the AI partner, which it said fights alongside you "rather than just standing by."

The enemies stood out too. Besides zombies, there are the new J'avo, which can plan attacks together, use weapons and heal themselves. Some mutate when hit, sometimes depending on where they're shot, with 15 mutations in all. Ryan McCaffrey of IGN called them some of the best enemy designs in the franchise's history. Richard George of IGN praised the world, lighting and creature work as "incredibly strong."

Some critics loved the excess. Game Informer called it an "unhinged flaming rollercoaster ride," and the Official Xbox Magazine praised its length and variety. Outside the campaigns, there's more to play:

  • Mercenaries: survive against hordes of enemies. On PC, a No Mercy sub-mode puts the Left 4 Dead 2 cast against 300 enemies on a timer.
  • Agent Hunt: take control of random enemies in other players' online sessions, available once you clear the three main campaigns.

Four campaigns, and only one most critics liked

The campaigns drew the hardest criticism. Simon Parkin of Eurogamer named Leon's as the strongest and "the closest we get to the series' survival horror roots," and he gave Ada's credit for its "diverse flavour." He was much harsher on the other two. Jake's campaign "rarely delights," and Chris's was a "second-rate third-person sprint" with "idiotic" dialogue in its cutscenes. Edge also noted how sharply the four differ in quality.

Others went further. Kevin VanOrd of GameSpot called the campaigns a test of patience for "even the most dedicated," and Destructoid called the game a "step back" even for ordinary action shooters. The cover system was a common complaint: GamesRadar said it "never seems to work right," and The Escapist called it "the most forgettable new feature of the game." Quick time events also show up often during certain actions.

Otero's point at 1Up.com sums up the problem: too many compromises and "too much empowerment" can wear away what makes Resident Evil work.

What the scores say

Metacritic rated it "mixed or average" and called it the first main-series game to miss a positive reception from critics. The critic aggregates show the same split: 65/100 for each of the Xbox 360, PlayStation 3 and Windows versions, with other tallies at 72/100 and 62/100, and one at just 21%. The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 6.6 out of 10.

That number fits the record. This is a capable, generous action game held back by two weak campaigns and a cover system nobody liked. Start with Leon's campaign, play it with a friend, and judge the rest from there.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet