Resident Evil 7 finds its fear in one Louisiana house, then loses it to bosses
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Critics found it terrifying, then lost patience with the bosses
Polygon's Philip Kollar wrote that no Resident Evil since the first had done as good a job at making him feel "scared and helpless". In the same review, he said the boss battles broke the suspense the rest of the game builds. Destructoid's Zack Furniss praised the pacing as "masterful" but called the final boss fight and the ending disappointing.
Most of the reception follows that split. The early hours inside the Baker house drew near-universal praise, and the late game drew most of the complaints. Critic aggregates put the game at 86 to 87 out of 100 across its versions, and the critic average, computed from those aggregates, is 8.6 out of 10.
The Baker house carries the game
You play Ethan Winters, a civilian searching for his wife Mia on the Baker family's derelict estate in Dulvey, Louisiana. The game is played in first person, a first for a main Resident Evil game. It drops the heavy action of Resident Evil 5 and 6 and puts exploration first.
The setting got the most praise. IGN's Chloi Rad called the plantation "one of the creepiest single settings since the Spencer Mansion", and GamesRadar+'s Leon Hurley said many of his favorite moments came from searching the "beautifully designed" house. Game Informer's Andrew Reiner liked how exploring each room revealed more about the family living there.
Rad also had the sharpest objection to the setting. She said the game leans on "overplayed tropes about rural America" until the Baker family starts to feel like a cartoon, and she called the puzzles the setting's one real weakness.
Weak guns and a small bag make every fight a choice
The game makes Ethan fragile on purpose. Guns hit softer than in the action-heavy entries, enemies sidestep and block, and downed enemies get back up. Often the better choice is to crouch, sneak past or run. Ethan starts with eight inventory slots plus four D-pad shortcuts, and backpacks add more space. Safe rooms hold item boxes and tape recorders for saving.
- Furniss liked the tension that limited resources created.
- PC Gamer's Andy Kelly called Ethan's constant vulnerability one of the game's greatest strengths.
- EGMNow's Ray Carsillo disliked that ammunition and weapons take up the same scarce slots as key story items.
- GameSpot's Scott Butterworth felt enemies weren't threatening enough for the difficulty level.
There are three difficulty settings. Madhouse opens up after you finish the game, and it makes you spend a cassette tape every time you save.
VHS tapes and VR got the most excited reviews
Throughout the estate, Ethan finds VHS tapes he can play in VCRs. Each one lets you play a short scene as the person who filmed it. Butterworth said the tapes work "beautifully as both a narrative device and a way to break up Ethan's exhausting mission", and Kelly named them one of his favorite features.
Critics disagreed about the first-person view. Giant Bomb's Dan Ryckert called it "bold". Kelly argued the opposite: the game is "classic Resident Evil through and through".
Critics who played on PlayStation VR said it made the game more frightening, with Carsillo calling it "even more frightening than doing it normally". The costs were specific. Furniss noted that resolution drops in VR, and the body movements required in seated VR mode were described as stomach-churning. Butterworth also found weaker colors and textures on Xbox One than on other platforms.
Where the last act slips
Critics' complaints about the second half have something in common. Butterworth felt the excitement fade as certain tasks repeated. Hurley questioned a choice near the end, arguing that a player who regrets it can quickly undo it, which makes the choice feel unimportant. Reiner said Ethan's thin characterization makes the plot inconsistent. Kollar's point about the bosses applies here too: they replace the suspense with a set-piece fight.
The game is strongest when Ethan is weak, alone and hiding. It is weakest when it asks him to stand and fight something large.
None of the critics who raised these complaints said they spoiled what came before. Kelly summed up the case for the game as a return to the original's "atmospheric, slow-burning horror", and the late-game problems didn't change that judgment.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Resident Evil 7: Biohazard en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q24577667 wikidata.org