Resistance 3 is a darker, sharper shooter that critics still called familiar
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The level design split the critics
Critics disagreed most about the levels you fight through. GameSpot praised an exciting, deep campaign and said players were "in for a treat" whatever their setup. Game Informer described almost the opposite: "bland environments", "predictable" level design and "numerous glitches" that could stop the game cold.
Both can be true, depending on what you want from a shooter. GameSpot was judging the pace and the set pieces. Game Informer was judging the spaces between them and how well the game held together. A player who wants steady action will probably side with GameSpot. A player who wants levels that surprise them, or who has little patience for bugs, should take Game Informer's warning seriously.
The Daily Telegraph called it one of the most enjoyable action games in years, but it opened that praise with "connection issues aside".
Familiar, not bad, was the usual complaint
Most of the mixed verdicts weren't about quality. They were about novelty. The A.V. Club gave it a B+ and said it "delivers the goods", but called them goods players already had, repackaged. The Guardian gave it four stars and found it "fast, furious and entertaining" while missing the uniqueness that would put it at the top of the genre. Metro UK went lowest of the named outlets with a 7 out of 10, calling it the most accomplished game in the series yet still behind the best shooters of its day.
Others read the same familiarity as a strength. Digital Spy said it didn't rewrite the book on first-person shooters but offered a low learning curve, intuitive controls and a strong story. It also said newcomers would find it a good place to start. Common Sense Media called it the best entry in the franchise. In Japan, Famitsu scored it 34 out of 40.
So the dividing line is simple. If you have played a lot of shooters and want something you haven't seen, the record suggests you'll find this one competent rather than fresh. If you want a well-built campaign and don't care whether it breaks new ground, critics gave you plenty of reasons to pick it up.
The darker tone is the real change
The biggest shift from the first two games is mood. Resistance 3 moves away from the military feel of Fall of Man and Resistance 2 toward post-apocalyptic survival horror. IGN called it the darkest and most violent game in the series and singled out the second act as the stretch that keeps you on edge. It carries a Mature 17+ and PEGI 18 rating, and that tone is the reason.
The design backs up the setting. Humans build their weapons from whatever scrap they can find. The new tools include:
- the Mutator, which sprays a biological mist that eventually makes enemies explode and damages anything nearby;
- the Deadeye, a sniper rifle;
- a shrapnel grenade built from a food can, which throws a shower of nails.
Favorites like the Bullseye, Magnum, Rossmore, Auger, Marksman and Carbine return. Weapons get stronger the more you use them, which rewards sticking with a few you like. The weapon wheel and health bar from the first game are back too. That's a deliberate step away from the regenerating-health style Metro hinted at when it mentioned the game abandoning what Halo introduced.
Half of what critics reviewed is gone
At launch, the package included 16-player online matches in five modes (Team Deathmatch, Chain Reaction, Deathmatch, Breach and Capture the Flag) with a loadout progression system, plus two-player story co-op online or split-screen. GameSpot counted the multiplayer as a highlight.
Sony turned off the Resistance servers on April 8, 2014. The online competitive modes and online co-op went with them, so any praise for the multiplayer no longer describes something you can buy. Judge Resistance 3 on its campaign.
For hardware, the game supports a PlayStation Move motion controller, the Sharp Shooter rifle attachment and stereoscopic 3D. They're optional extras, and none of the critics here made them the reason to play.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Resistance 3 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q2531844 wikidata.org