Rise of the Tomb Raider saves its best work for the optional tombs
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Most fights let you choose quiet or loud
Much of Rise of the Tomb Raider comes down to a choice made in the seconds before a fight. Lara Croft can hide in bushes, throw a distraction to pull guards away and pick enemies off with a bow. Or she can open fire with assault rifles, shotguns and pistols, several of which have an alternate firing mode. The level itself offers weapons too: explosive barrels, rope-wrapped structures that rope arrows can tear down, and high ground for ambushes. Up close, she uses her ice axe and combat knife.
Critics mostly liked how this plays out. GameSpot's Mike Mahardy called the combat "superb" and credited the freedom to experiment. Spencer Campbell of Electronic Gaming Monthly found the stealth satisfyingly hard and the bigger arsenal more strategic. The complaints were about volume. Game Informer's Kimberly Wallace found the later fights repetitive, and Justin Towell of GamesRadar said there was so much killing that Lara often felt like a "cold-blooded killer." Destructoid's Steven Hansen made a related point: the game keeps the 2013 reboot's gap between the violence you commit and the story told about Lara.
Skill trees and crafting reward a plan
Kills, objectives and side content earn XP, and each level-up gives a skill point for one of three trees. Brawler improves weapon handling and toughness and adds moves like the dodge kill. Hunter covers animals and the terrain. Survivor covers things like incendiary bombs and booby traps. Wallace liked that the trees fit different play styles.
Crafting feeds the same loop. Cans and bottles become Molotov cocktails and hand grenades, death-cap mushrooms become poisoned arrows, and hunted wildlife supplies more materials. A vision mode called Survival Instinct highlights what's worth picking up. Mahardy thought the crafting was well built but the gathering tedious, and Towell felt there was too much to collect. IGN's Lucy O'Brien saw the upside: the new crafting options made otherwise uninspired fights more fun.
The hubs are uneven, but the challenge tombs shine
Between story chapters, the game opens into semi-open hubs. Lara climbs cliffs and glaciers with her ice axe, strings ziplines with rope arrows, climbs trees and swims. Base camps let her swap outfits and weapon loadouts and act as fast travel points. The puzzles run on in-game physics and often link together, so several small solutions add up to a bigger one.
Critics who disagreed about the hubs still tended to agree about the tombs: the optional ones are worth the detour.
Wallace liked the interconnected world design, said the large hubs pulled her into exploring, and found the tombs deeper and more intricate than the previous game's. O'Brien called the challenge tombs the highlight and a nod to older Tomb Raider games, though she wanted more puzzles. Campbell said the optional tomb puzzles made up for the weak story, and Mahardy praised a "waterfall structure" where each action opens new options. The dissent was sharp. Towell found the hubs full of aimless filler, and Hansen called much of it "open world busywork," comparing it to the Assassin's Creed series.
Siberia looks superb, and the plot plays it safe
The presentation drew the most consistent praise. Wallace called the graphics "stunning" but noted frame rate drops. Campbell said every location looked unique, Towell singled out the animation, and Hansen ranked it among the best-looking games available, apart from some lighting he found unrealistic.
The story, about Lara's search for the city of Kitezh and its promise of immortality while the paramilitary group Trinity chases the same prize, split reviewers. Campbell called it simple and formulaic, borrowing too much from Raiders of the Lost Ark. Mahardy found it emotional and grounded. Towell enjoyed its surprises but thought it stayed too close to the 2013 reboot. The lead role fared better: Game Revolution's Peter Paras praised Luddington's performance as Lara, and O'Brien called her "endearing."
Expeditions add replay value, at a price
There's no multiplayer this time. Instead, Expeditions let you replay the game under new rules in four modes: Chapter Replay, Chapter Replay Elite (which carries over skills and weapons you've already earned), Score Attack and Remnant Resistance. Paras called the mode a "real treat." Eurogamer's Oli Welsh saw no reason for it beyond pleasing YouTubers and selling microtransactions. Even without it, Wallace called the game "better in every way" than its predecessor and highly replayable.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Rise of the Tomb Raider en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q17154489 wikidata.org