Analysis · Rocksmith 2014

Rocksmith 2014 swaps the plastic controller for a real guitar

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

High praise, and complaints that are mostly about cost

The strongest praise came from Lee Cooper of Hardcore Gamer. Cooper wrote that every part of the game improved on 2011's Rocksmith, and that the original's known problems were either removed or "overhauled beyond recognition." Metacritic's numbers back that up: 89/100 on PC, 87/100 on Xbox 360 and 86/100 on PlayStation 3.

Critics raised few complaints about the design. The real problems are about what it takes to play. You need an electric guitar or bass guitar and a USB adapter cable. An acoustic guitar may also need a pickup. And the 66 songs on the disc are a small part of a catalog of over a thousand, which are sold as paid DLC.

Reviews were mostly positive. The praise covers what happens once a guitar is plugged in, and the costs are getting it plugged in and stocked with songs.

A replacement for Rocksmith, not a follow-up

Ubisoft announced the game at its 2013 E3 presentation, and it has been described as a replacement for the first Rocksmith rather than a sequel. The basic idea is the same. Instead of a plastic controller like the ones in Guitar Hero, you plug in almost any real electric guitar or bass guitar, using a cable that fits the standard 1⁄4 in (6.35 mm) output jack.

Most of the changes are about how you progress. The original made you start every song at its lowest difficulty. Rocksmith 2014 lets you set the difficulty yourself. It also has three separate paths for lead guitar, rhythm guitar and bass, plus missions that point you toward the skills you're weakest at. Those changes match Hardcore Gamer's view that the original's frustrations had been dealt with rather than patched over.

It's built to teach as much as to entertain

This version leans harder into teaching than the original did. It has more than 85 lessons covering techniques like bends, accents and slides, along with a new tool that shows where your fingers should go on the neck. There's also a mode for colorblind players.

Around the lessons are modes meant to keep practice from feeling like homework:

  • Session Mode lets you jam with in-game musicians.
  • Master Mode was improved to help you play songs from memory.
  • Guitarcade minigames practice specific skills in short arcade rounds.

If you want a song list to perform, it's a music game. If you want to play guitar without the screen, it's a course, and that's the part critics valued most.

What you need before you start

  • An electric guitar or bass guitar with a standard output jack. An acoustic guitar may need an added pickup.
  • The USB adapter cable the game recommends.
  • A PC or Mac, a PlayStation 3 or Xbox 360 (October 2013), or a PlayStation 4 or Xbox One (November 2014).
  • A budget for DLC if the 66 songs on the disc don't cover the music you want to learn.

It's rated Teen and supports both single-player and multiplayer. If you already own a guitar, the only required extra is the cable, and that's when this is easiest to recommend. If you'd have to buy an instrument first, think of the game as a course that comes with a large shop of extra songs.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet