Rome II made Total War bigger and more political, but it launched broken
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The eighth Total War went back to Rome with many more nations
Total War: Rome II is the eighth standalone game in Creative Assembly's Total War series and the successor to the 2004 Rome: Total War. Sega published it on September 3, 2013, two years after Total War: Shogun 2, and critics measured it against both games.
The core is the same as before. A turn-based grand strategy campaign handles cities, armies and diplomacy, and real-time battles settle the fighting. The campaign starts in 272 BC at the end of the Pyrrhic War and covers 300 years of Europe, the Mediterranean and the Near East. There are no timed victory conditions, so a campaign can run past that.
The biggest change is how the map is populated. In the original, minor states were lumped together as a single "rebel nation." According to lead unit designer Jack Lusted, Rome II gives smaller nations and city-states their own factions instead. Each ethnic group has its own play style, its own agents and its own technologies, so a Gallic tribe doesn't fight like a Roman legion. The game has over 500 land units, mercenaries included, and more than 30 city variants so sieges don't keep playing out the same way.
Politics at home now matter as much as wars abroad
Rome II rebuilds the series' politics from scratch. Rome and Carthage each have three political groups competing for power, and you join one when you choose the faction. Other factions split power between a ruling family and a class of nobles.
Political standing works like a resource, and it rises and falls with what your generals and characters actually do. If it drops too low, you lose your say over the nation's affairs. If it climbs too high, rivals may band together against you. Pushing for total power to become emperor or king means civil war, which was also redesigned.
The decision prompts from Shogun 2 return and now form "decision paths," where earlier choices shape later ones. That's how the Roman Republic can become the Roman Empire through civil war. Diplomacy got a new AI too, because Creative Assembly admitted earlier games let tiny factions declare suicidal wars on huge ones. These systems are the strongest case that Rome II is more than a visual upgrade.
The battles are what critics praised most
New unit cameras let you zoom in on a single soldier in a fight that can hold thousands. Creative Assembly said it wanted to show the human side of war, with soldiers reacting when the men beside them fall and officers rallying their troops with speeches.
Critics responded to that scale. PC Gamer scored the game 85% and called the battles "stunning." Edge also praised the visuals and the fighting. Daniel Starkey of GameSpot liked the range of units and the sound design, but he called the camera and controls "problematic" in sieges and big field battles. Justin Clouse of The Escapist said the game gives every faction a unique feel, which supports the series' biggest bet on variety.
A rough launch, and a free fix a year later
On release, players reported failed loads after installing, crashes, texture problems, broken AI and poor performance. Rich Stanton of The Guardian wrote that his PC ran Shogun 2 on ultra settings but Rome II on medium made it "choke like a dog." Creative Director Mike Simpson apologized on the official forums and promised more patches, and the first one came out the Friday of launch week.
Some complaints went deeper than bugs:
- Steve Butts of IGN reported turns taking as long as 10 minutes while the AI factions moved.
- Adam Biessener of Game Informer called it a "step backwards" from Shogun 2, because the campaign slows down well before its endgame.
- Paul Dean of Eurogamer saw only modest progress: "a bit bigger, a bit better."
Not every critic agreed. Mike Suskle of GamesRadar called it a worthy continuation of the franchise.
The Emperor Edition, released 16 September 2014, came out as a standalone release and as a free update for existing owners. It rolled in the earlier fixes and improved AI battles, the political system, building chains and the visuals. Softpedia scored it 90. Nothing in the update notes mentions turn times or campaign pacing, though, so Game Informer's complaint is the one fix you shouldn't count on.
Judge Rome II by the Emperor Edition, not by its launch.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Total War: Rome II en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q863643 wikidata.org