Rory McIlroy PGA Tour plays a better round of golf with far less to do
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A new name on the box and a new engine underneath
Rory McIlroy PGA Tour is an entry in EA Sports' PGA Tour franchise, and it's the first one since 1999 that doesn't carry Tiger Woods's name. Rory McIlroy replaces him. EA Tiburon built it for PlayStation 4 and Xbox One only, with no version for older consoles, and it runs on the Frostbite engine.
That clean start explains both halves of the reception. The new technology changed how the game plays, and critics mostly liked that. The rebuild also came at a cost. Large parts of PGA Tour 14 didn't make the move, and critics were much harder on that.
Frostbite changed how the ball behaves
The biggest gain is in the physics. The ball now responds to how firm the ground is and how long the grass is, and it can travel through plants and trees. Each course is treated as one connected map, so a wild shot that would once have been ruled out of bounds and penalized can now be played from wherever it lands.
Polygon credited the engine for the game's looks, its short loading times and its ball physics. IGN called the courses clearly better than the previous generation's, while noting flat textures and course features that pop in along the ball's flight path.
The swing options got just as much praise. There are three main modes:
- Arcade swings with the analog sticks and lets you add spin while the ball is in the air.
- 3-Click is the traditional timing-based swing.
- Tour works like Arcade but turns off every assist and raises the sensitivity.
A new backswing meter, an aiming arc and putt reads help newer players, and each assist can be turned on or off on its own. IGN liked that this lets players fit the game to their style, and Polygon singled out the new putting system. Polygon also praised a career progression that lets you build a balanced set of skills instead of locking your golfer into pure power or pure accuracy.
What was cut from PGA Tour 14
The list of cuts is long, and it's the reason the scores ended up where they did. Compared with PGA Tour 14, the game drops:
- women's events, along with amateur events except for one Web.com Tour event used to earn your PGA Tour card;
- alternate scoring formats such as Stableford, leaving only stroke play and match play;
- the option to play single holes or selected types of holes (you can play the front 9, the back 9 or all 18);
- online Country Clubs Quick Tournament, weather and career schedules.
IGN said the career mode felt these cuts most, since it lost bonus objectives, practice rounds and the trophy room. It wrote that the "slash and burn" of features was especially hard to accept after a two-year wait for a game released only on new hardware. Polygon's verdict put the problem neatly:
"a smooth-playing game of golf, which makes the inability to use its new gameplay on the old features fans loved even more regrettable."
Eight real courses and no Augusta
The disc includes eight real courses: Bay Hill, Chambers Bay, the Old Course at St. Andrews, Royal Troon, TPC Boston, TPC Sawgrass, Whistling Straits and Wolf Creek. TPC Scottsdale was a pre-order bonus. Augusta National and the Masters are missing because the license expired, so Polygon noted that only two of the men's majors are represented.
Four fantasy courses fill out the list, including the Grand Canyon, a course based on the Battlefield 4 map Paracel Storm and a nightclub-themed course for the new Night Club Challenge, where you hit shots at targets. Polygon found that mode fun but said it couldn't match earlier modes built around golf's history.
Polygon called the crowds "lifelike" and preferred the Golf Channel commentary to the old booth, though it said the lines repeat. Polygon also criticized the limited character creation.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Rory McIlroy PGA Tour en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q17182360 wikidata.org