Analysis · Metroid: Samus Returns

Samus Returns rebuilds a 1991 Game Boy hunt around a melee counter

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The counter sets the pace, for better and worse

Samus Returns is a side-scrolling game drawn in 2.5D, and its fights turn on one move. When an enemy lunges with a physical attack, a visual cue flashes and Samus can swing her Arm Cannon in a Melee Counter that stuns the attacker. A clean counter leaves her in a strong position. Against Metroids, her next shot comes out fully charged and she can fire several Missiles in a row.

She can also aim freely in any direction. That is a clear break from Metroid II, where her shots were locked to set angles, and it changes how every room plays.

Most critics liked the result. Andrew Webster at The Verge called the combat "fast and fluid", GameSpot's Peter Brown found it more aggressive and satisfying than he expected, and Polygon's Russ Frushtick counted the counter as a major improvement for 2D Metroid. Eurogamer's Martin Robinson was the sharpest dissent. He argued the counter gives the action a "staccato rhythm", stopping Samus again and again for one-note encounters.

A Metroid hunt that tells you where to look

The Galactic Federation hires Samus to wipe out the parasitic Metroid species on their home planet, SR388. The story and structure follow the 1991 original: explore maze-like caverns, defeat hostile aliens, collect power-ups and use them to open new areas. Later series staples join in, including the Grapple Beam, Power Bombs and Super Missiles, and Teleport Stations let Samus fast travel between areas.

The biggest structural change is the Aeion abilities, which draw on their own energy gauge. The Scan Pulse reveals hidden pathways and items around Samus, and it split critics:

  • Nintendo Life's Chris Scullion found it useful and said it made the game "far more entertaining".
  • Brown at GameSpot felt it took away some of the thrill of finding secrets yourself.

Both points hold. For a remake of a game whose caves could be confusing, the scan makes the hunt friendlier. For players who love Metroid because secrets have to be earned, it hands over answers a little too easily.

The controls ask a lot of your hands

Samus carries a lot of weapons and abilities, and the 3DS has to map all of them. IGN's Samuel Claiborn said switching between them meant working the shoulder buttons, slider and face buttons in a "downright painful" way. Robinson at Eurogamer agreed that the remake fixed problems in the original but still found it underwhelming.

Strong combat ideas can still feel clumsy when every tool shares a small set of buttons.

That is the main reason the game falls short of the very top of the series. The ideas are good. Using all of them at once is where some critics struggled.

One of the best-looking and best-sounding 3DS games

Critics praised the presentation more than anything else. Frushtick called the visuals "remarkable". Webster thought the 3D graphics made the game easier and more playable than Metroid II, and that the handheld's glasses-free 3D added a "wonderful" sense of depth. Game Informer's Ben Reeves found the environments rich in detail, with art inspired by the Metroid Prime games.

Daisuke Matsuoka's soundtrack also won praise, and Destructoid's Chris Carter called its melodies "hauntingly beautiful". The awards followed: Best Handheld Game at The Game Awards 2017, Handheld Game of the Year at the 21st Annual D.I.C.E. Awards and IGN's Best 3DS Game of 2017.

What's left after the credits, and what's behind figurines

Finishing the game unlocks a standard Hard Mode, with no extra purchase needed. Most of the other bonus content depends on Amiibo figurines based on the Metroid series. Scanning them adds reserve tanks and a Metroid Marker that points to nearby Metroids. After one completion, figurine owners also get two art galleries, a Sound Test and Fusion Mode, an extra-hard setting with Samus in her Fusion Suit.

Locking the hardest mode behind a figurine is a poor choice for players who want the full challenge. Without the figurines, you get the main game and Hard Mode.

Aggregate critic scores ranged from 73/100 to 89%, and Metacritic called the reviews "generally favorable". The critic average of 8.0, computed from those critic aggregates, fits: the craft is excellent, with a couple of design choices that held back some critics.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet