San Andreas built a whole state, then made you drive across it
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Praised as console gaming's best, faulted on race and pacing
Few games of 2004 drew praise this high. Game Informer's Andrew Reiner called Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas "entertainment at its best", and PSM2's Daniel Dawkins ranked its world second only to The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time in console history. Metacritic lists it as the fifth-highest-rated PlayStation 2 game, and the critic average, computed from five critics, is 9.6.
The sharpest objections came from two directions. The New York Times's Charles Herold argued that the game's structure wears its missions down: long drives to reach them, then long stretches to replay after a failure. Seeing Black's Esther Iverem and the scholar Dean Chan faulted its picture of Black life as a set of stereotypes the game never questions. Both complaints hold up next to the praise. Neither cancels it.
A state-sized map with three cities that feel different
San Andreas is a fictional US state in 1992, split between Los Santos, San Fierro and Las Venturas, with countryside in between. The cities open up as the story moves on, and airports let you fast travel between them. More than 180 vehicles fill the roads, the water and the sky, and most of them take modifications like hydraulics, nitrous oxide engines and stereo systems.
Critics treated the world as the main event. 1Up.com's Jeremy Parish praised the freeway system and the social dynamics. IGN's Jeremy Dunham picked out how the weather differs from city to city, and GameSpy's Miguel Lopez praised how closely it mimics the American West Coast. PALGN's Chris Sell called it "visually absorbing", and critics agreed the lighting, foliage and animation were a step up from Vice City.
The PlayStation 2 paid for it. Several reviewers ran into pop-in and unstable frame rates, and some felt the game pushed the console to its limit.
Varied missions, but getting to them drags
Story missions are linear jobs with set goals. Between them you can roam, take territory from rival gangs and defend it, or pick up side work such as taxi, firefighting, paramedic and vigilante jobs. Dawkins found the missions rarely repetitive and good at mixing difficulty with comedy, and GameRevolution's Joe Dodson praised the freedom.
Not everyone agreed. Parish felt the improvisation of earlier games was gone, and Electronic Gaming Monthly's Dan Hsu wanted branching paths. Other critics echoed Herold's complaint about long drives and long replays. Reviewers also faulted the combat targeting, though they granted that auto-aim helps, and the controls for flying, racing, RC cars and minigames.
The new role-playing layer went over better. CJ's weight, muscle, stamina, lung capacity, driving and gun skills shift with what he does, and you can spend cash on clothes, haircuts and tattoos. Critics called the system simple, subtle and effective. Parish's main complaint was that some missions are locked behind stat requirements.
CJ gives the series its strongest story to that point
CJ comes home after his mother's murder, finds his old street gang in decline and sets about rebuilding it while clashing with corrupt authorities and rival criminals. Several critics rated it the best story in the series so far, and Eurogamer's Kristan Reed credited the dialogue and scene-setting, both inside and outside cutscenes.
Reviewers singled out Young Maylay, Samuel L. Jackson, James Woods and David Cross. Official U.S. PlayStation Magazine's John Davison called CJ possibly one of the most believable characters in games. Parish agreed, but saw a tension: CJ is kind, which makes the violence the game asks of him harder to believe.
The argument over race cuts both ways
This is where the game is still contested. Chan argued that switching from an Italian American lead to an African American one without challenging the archetypes made the series complicit. Paul Barrett said it strips institutional racism of its context and blames hardship on individual failure.
Others read it differently. Rachael Hutchinson called it "a critical reflection" on racial conflict in America and argued that many critics had seen only parts of the story. A Games and Culture study found that African American players used it to talk about institutional racism, while white players raised concerns about its stereotypes. Parish praised its references to the Rodney King assault and its writing about race in South Central Los Angeles.
Go in expecting a story that some scholars read as a sharp look at race and others read as a caricature. Both readings come from people who took the game seriously.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q83265 wikidata.org