Screamride's coaster wrecking won critics over even when its modes didn't
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A great surprise to some, an identity crisis to others
The praise and the criticism on record are about as far apart as they get. Game Revolution's Nick Tan gave Screamride 4.5/5 and called it a "surprisingly remarkable" Xbox exclusive. Polygon's Arthur Gies gave it 8/10 and named it "one of the first great surprises of 2015."
GamesRadar's David Robert gave it 2.5/5 and said the game has "an identity crisis." In his view it falls apart whenever it tries to be anything other than a coaster builder, and he found the scenarios boring and the presentation dull.
The averages land in between: 71/100 on Metacritic from 54 reviews and 75.19% on GameRankings from 36. The critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 7.4 out of 10. Most of the disagreement comes down to one question: whether three different modes make one game.
Three modes, and the fight over whether they fit
Screamride has more than 50 levels split across three modes:
- Engineer: build or fix coasters and thrill rides to meet set conditions with limited resources.
- ScreamRider: ride a coaster and steer it, trying to keep the riders from falling off.
- Demolition Expert: fling cabins full of people at buildings and objects to meet goals and score points.
Tan said the modes fit together cohesively and test you from several angles. IGN's Miranda Sanchez also liked having three distinct modes. Robert saw them as cut off from each other, isolated pieces rather than a whole. GameSpot's Kevin VanOrd fell in between: he liked Demolition Expert most and called it close to "a 3D version of Angry Birds," while finding the building modes more limited.
Destruction is the part nearly everyone liked
Every piece of a coaster can be destroyed. Pull out one section and the cars derail. A wrecked coaster can take buildings down with it, and a well-placed crash can set off explosions and chain reactions that topple a skyscraper.
That system earned the most consistent praise. Sanchez called the destruction and explosions satisfying and described the play as strategic and rewarding. Gies singled out the environmental destruction and the "excellent" puzzle design, and liked the room the game leaves for experimenting. Even Game Informer's Joe Juba, one of the cooler reviewers at 6.5/10, liked the colorful graphics.
Sanchez also praised the Engineer controls as simple but deep enough for intricate coasters, so the building side has defenders too.
Where it trips: difficulty, tech and a fenced-in sandbox
The complaints are specific and come from several outlets:
- Sanchez flagged a frustrating difficulty spike in the career mode, plus occasional camera and framerate problems.
- VanOrd found real limits in the Engineer and sandbox modes. He said your enjoyment depends on letting go of RollerCoaster Tycoon and its freedom.
- Juba disliked that sandbox pieces stay locked until you reach certain points in the campaign. He also called the voice acting unremarkable and the soundtrack repetitive, and felt the charm wore off as the game went on.
- Gies, despite his high score, found the sheer number of coaster pieces and environment types overwhelming.
Critics didn't agree on the music either: Sanchez called it relaxing while Juba found it repetitive. The RollerCoaster Tycoon comparison matters most here. Some reviewers called Screamride a spiritual successor to that game, but VanOrd's review suggests that label sets the wrong expectations. This is a puzzle game with a building toolkit, not a park manager.
The online side is mostly gone
There's no multiplayer. At launch, the Xbox One version let you ride coasters other players had built and shared, and race to ride a coaster as fast as possible while building up a "scream rating." Most of those features have since been discontinued, though the game also has an online leaderboard.
That matters because Tan counted level sharing as a source of free content. Take that away and what's left is the 50-plus campaign levels and the sandbox, set in the year 2400 at a company called Screamworks that hires thrill-seekers to test extreme rides. The core puzzles and destruction critics liked are still there. The steady stream of player-made coasters is mostly not.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Screamride en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q18536867 wikidata.org