Sea of Thieves shines with a crew of friends and sags when you sail alone
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Built for a crew that already likes each other
Sea of Thieves was made for a group of friends who want a shared playground, not for players who want a story to follow. It's a first-person pirate game set in one shared world. You take voyages from trading companies, dig up treasure and sell it at outposts for gold and reputation. Other crews are out on the same ocean, and they may help you or rob you.
For that group, critics agreed it delivers. Game Informer's Kyle Hilliard said each session "results in a story", and GamesRadar's Sam Loveridge called it "an anecdote generator at its very best". IGN's Brandin Tyrrel put it most plainly: it works when treated "like a chat room or a party game".
Running a ship is the best part
The ship is where the design pays off. Solo and duo players get a small, quick sloop. A crew of three takes a brigantine, and four players take a galleon. On the bigger ships, players split up the jobs:
- steering the ship
- firing the cannons
- navigating
- boarding enemy ships
- scouting from the crow's nest
Damage below deck lets water in, so someone has to patch holes with planks while someone else bails with a bucket. That kind of shared panic is what Destructoid's Jordan Devore meant when he said a full crew can get chaotic and volatile very quickly. Tyrrel praised the ship combat, and Eurogamer's Christian Donlan called it "thrilling". Critics also singled out the graphics and the physics.
Crews can form alliances. Allies fly the same flag and get half the gold and reputation when a partner sells treasure, but an alliance doesn't stop anyone from attacking you. That one rule sums up the game well: trust is always a gamble.
Where it falls short at launch
The trouble was what you do between fights. Devore found the quests repetitive. Game Revolution's Paul Tamburro said they had little variety and left little room for creativity. Loveridge called the voyages "elaborated fetch quests". Many critics also pointed out that quests only reward cosmetic items, so there's not much reason to keep doing them unless you enjoy the sailing for its own sake.
Player-versus-player combat drew complaints from both sides. Polygon's Russ Frushtick said misbehaving players can make sessions frustrating because PvP could never be turned off, yet he also felt the game gave no real reason to seek out fights. GameSpot's Peter Brown enjoyed working with other players but noted that some players were trolling others. Hilliard also found the hand-to-hand combat bland, and Tyrrel thought the respawn system was too forgiving. When you die and no one revives you in time, you wait on a ghost ship called the Ferry of the Damned before you return.
Solo sailing splits opinion
Critics split hardest on solo play. Some found it harder, dull and maddening. Others found it satisfying and relaxing. That split makes sense: a lone player on a sloop does every crew job alone and is easy prey for a full galleon.
One later change matters here. A player-versus-environment mode named Safer Seas arrived in December 2023, which answers the early complaint that PvP could never be disabled. A competitive mode called Arena came and went for low player numbers, and a PvP mode called Hourglass replaced it in Season 8.
A better game after a year of updates
Opinion on the game improved as it grew. After the Anniversary update, IGN told players it was the "perfect time" to return. David Jagneaux praised the Tall Tales and their riddles, and Polygon's Nicole Carpenter said the updates gave the game more structure and direction. PC Gamer named it Best Ongoing Game of 2019.
The early mixed scores reflect a thinner game than the one that exists now, but the core complaints about repetitive voyages and cosmetic-only rewards were never fully answered.
The critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 6.8 out of 10. The audience has stayed: the game reached 40 million players in April 2024.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Sea of Thieves en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q20113718 wikidata.org