Analysis · SCP: Secret Laboratory

Secret Laboratory is only as good as the strangers you spawn with

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A 57.4/100 and a five-star rating for the same game

Critics split hard on SCP: Secret Laboratory. One aggregate scored it 57.4/100 in June 2021. A month later, another outlet gave it five stars and called it a "Very Fine SCP Game." The critic average of 5.7 out of 10 is computed from those critic scores, so it reflects the low aggregate more than the written reviews do.

The written reviews lean positive. Critics argued less about the design than about the experience around it: the servers, the players and the noise those players make. That's the real dividing line, and it tells you a lot about who will enjoy this game.

The chaos is the game, for better and worse

Each round starts with players spawning into one of several roles inside Site-02, a containment facility mid-breach. Humans talk over proximity voice chat. The monsters, called SCPs, can talk to each other across the whole map. An intercom room in the Entrance Zone lets any human broadcast to the entire facility.

Elie Gould at PC Gamer, writing in 2025, called it confusing and very funny, and ranked it among the best co-op shooters Gould had played. The review credited the playable anomalies, the round structure and a wild player base for an "utterly unhinged experience."

Dean Clark at GameTyrant, writing in 2018, saw the same ingredients from the other side. Clark praised the gameplay and the sound design but said the intercom was regularly abused, while being careful to blame the community's trolling, not the game itself.

Both critics are describing the same thing. One enjoyed strangers shouting into a shared space; the other found it got in the way.

What a round asks of you

Your goal depends on where you spawn:

  • D-Class Personnel and Scientists try to escape alive. Escapees come back as Chaos Insurgents or Mobile Task Force units, depending on their side, unless an enemy detains them first, which flips them to the detainer's faction.
  • Facility Guards, MTF units and Chaos Insurgents fight the other faction and help their own civilians get out.
  • SCPs work together to kill every human. Only one of each can spawn per round, they can't use items, and they get no reinforcement waves. Their only way to add members is SCP-049, which can turn corpses into SCP-049-2.

Keycards, firearms and contained SCP items are scattered through four zones, and the best gear sits behind higher-clearance doors. The map is randomly generated each round, so routes have to be relearned rather than memorized.

Getting into a match was the old complaint

Clark's biggest complaint wasn't about any design choice. The GameTyrant review said creating and joining servers was hard, and called the game "a lot of fun" only if you could get it running. That was in 2018. The later praise from PC Gamer and Screen Rant doesn't repeat the complaint, though the record doesn't say whether it was ever fixed.

Jonah Schuhart at Screen Rant, writing in 2020, pitched it as an easy way into the SCP universe for people who have never read any of it. Because it's free and the download is small, Schuhart wrote, there's "no harm in trying it out." Price matters a lot for a game this divisive. A bad first round costs you a few minutes, not money.

Who should load it up

It suits players who enjoy unscripted multiplayer: betrayals, detained scientists switching sides, and someone singing over the intercom while a monster stalks the halls. A headset with a microphone makes a big difference, since so much of the game happens over proximity chat.

It's a poor fit if you want a tightly balanced competitive shooter or a solo horror story. Every critic who enjoyed it was really enjoying the other people. If random strangers on voice chat wear you out, the 57.4/100 will feel closer to the truth than the five stars.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet