Analysis · Killzone: Shadow Fall

Shadow Fall traded Killzone's crowded war zones for open levels and a drone

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The sixth Killzone jumped 30 years past the war

Killzone: Shadow Fall is the sixth and most recent Killzone. It arrived as a PlayStation 4 launch title on November 15, 2013 in North America and November 29 in Europe. Guerrilla Games set it 30 years after Killzone 3 and brought in a new cast. You play Lucas Kellan, a Shadow Marshal investigating a new threat in the long war between Vekta and the Helghast.

The fresh start mattered. The series had built its name on crowded, linear battlefields with allies all around you. Shadow Fall moves further from that formula than any earlier entry, and the critics who liked it most liked it for exactly that reason.

Wider levels and a drone replaced the squad

The biggest change is level design. Missions are more open, with several routes to each objective, and stealth is now a real alternative to a straight firefight. For the first half of the campaign you fight alone, with the OWL drone as your only companion. It can attack or stun nearby enemies, lay down cover fire, raise an energy shield, deploy a zip line on the spot, and hack terminals and alarms so reinforcements never arrive. Later, an ally named Echo sometimes joins you and snipes the enemies you mark.

Destructoid's Dale North gave it 9/10 and praised the "sandbox-ish" levels and the stealth sections that break up the shooting. Eurogamer's Oli Welsh called the OWL a "fun tactical toy". IGN's Colin Moriarty saw the game as a "very welcome direction" for the series.

Not everyone found the open spaces worth exploring. GameSpot's Kevin VanOrd called the single-player campaign disappointing and said what he remembered was wandering through corridors and meadows looking for someone to shoot. Even IGN, which scored it 8 out of 10, criticized the AI and parts of the level design.

The guns and the old war stayed put

Underneath the changes, this is still a science fiction first-person shooter. Series regulars return in new forms: the M82 Assault Rifle, the StA-52 Assault Rifle and the StA-18 pistol. The main new weapon is the LSR44, a recoil-free rifle that switches between assault fire and charged sniper shots, a bit like a small rail gun. VanOrd missed Killzone 3's jump pack, which had made fights feel quicker and lighter on their feet.

Story and AI drew the most complaints. Polygon's Arthur Gies gave it 5 out of 10, praising the visuals but describing a game full of shooter cliches and poor execution, and he ranked it last among the launch shooters. GamesRadar's Ryan Taljonick, who gave it 4/5, found the characters unconvincing but said the story still had some powerful moments.

Multiplayer was the steadier half

Competitive play shipped with a simpler structure than earlier entries:

  • 10 maps at launch.
  • Custom match presets called Warzones that players can share, and that the community can promote.
  • Three classes, Assault, Scout and Support, with some older medic abilities folded into Support.
  • Every class, ability and weapon available from the start, with skill upgrades earned through class challenges.
  • A 4-player online co-op mode, added with the Intercept expansion on June 24, 2014.

Critics broadly liked it. VanOrd said the online side is where the game recovers from its campaign, though GamesRadar saw it more as a well-made distraction than somewhere to settle in for the long haul. It also brought legal trouble: in August 2014, Sony faced a $5 million class action that accused it of deceptive marketing because multiplayer didn't run at the advertised resolution. The case was dismissed on April 22, 2015.

A showpiece that critics expected to fade

Critics praised the visuals more than anything else. IGN called them "stunning" and named it Best PS4 Shooter and Best PS4 Graphics, and it won the People's Choice award in both categories too. Welsh put the catch neatly: new PS4 owners would be proud to show it off, but he doubted they'd still remember it by the next console generation.

Critic aggregates land between 71 and 77 out of 100, which matches the reviews: well made and good looking, but not remembered for long.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet