Shadow of Mordor's orcs remember every fight, and that memory carries the game
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The game is built on enemies who keep score
Everything in Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor depends on the Nemesis System. Orc captains remember their earlier run-ins with Talion and react to them the next time they meet. An orc who kills you can come back stronger and boast about it. One you scarred can return carrying the wound and a grudge.
Critics treated this as the main reason the game stands out. Lucas Sullivan of GamesRadar wrote that it made the villains memorable and gave the hero more personality. Brad Shoemaker of Giant Bomb said it produced many distinctive characters. Joystiq's Alexander Sliwinski said it set the game apart from other action games because no two runs play out the same way.
Not everyone was convinced. Chris Carter of Destructoid called it a gimmick: the orcs got new looks and weaknesses but no real personality. The fairest reading is that it works best as a source of stories, and a captain is only as interesting as your history with that captain.
Combat is strong enough to stand without the gimmick
Fighting is where the Nemesis idea pays off minute to minute. The combat uses free-flowing melee, counters and dodges, and attack chains that build toward special moves. Talion can also draw on Celebrimbor's wraith powers: slow time while aiming the bow, drain an enemy's focus, and later brand an orc so it fights on his side. Branding is the strongest link to the central idea, since it turns the grudge system into a tool you can use.
Shoemaker and Sliwinski both compared the rhythm of the fights to the Batman: Arkham series and found them fluid. Both also said the combat alone would make the game worth playing. Shoemaker described the mix of combat and Nemesis as "chaotic, emergent nonsense", meant as praise for the kind of open world it creates. Kevin VanOrd of GameSpot called it an improvement on the Assassin's Creed formula.
The main complaint came from Matt Miller of Game Informer, who found the constant focus on killing repetitive.
The story doesn't share the system's memory
This is where the central idea falls short. The Nemesis System gives you rivals with history, while the main plot follows a fixed line: Talion, a Gondorian Ranger, is killed along with his family and brought back by Celebrimbor's wraith to get revenge on Sauron's forces. The game is set between the events of The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings films.
Critics were split. Shoemaker and Sliwinski liked the dark tone. Others found real problems:
- VanOrd called the story erratic and weighed down by anticlimactic fights.
- Miller said the ending fails to tie the plot threads together.
- Dan Stapleton of IGN said the characters were memorable but the story wouldn't make sense to series fans, and interest faded toward the end.
- Carter summed it up as "go here, kill this" and found the side missions more interesting than the campaign.
Several critics also felt the Nemesis System itself fades late in the game. Miller said it fell flat in the final hours, and VanOrd found it unappealing until the second half. A game built on memory seems to struggle when its own scripted ending takes over.
Lots to do in Mordor, but not all of it new
Outside the main missions, Mordor is packed. There are Gollum missions about Celebrimbor's past, missions to free human slaves from the Uruk armies, weapon quests for the sword, bow and dagger, plus hunting, herb gathering, artifacts and Elvish seals. Strongholds raise an alarm and call in more Uruks if Talion is spotted, so stealth matters there.
Sullivan called the number of collectibles "staggering" and enjoyed the lore. Miller praised the soundtrack and voice acting. On the other side, Sullivan found some side missions repetitive, Sliwinski didn't like some boss fights, and Carter was annoyed by unskippable cutscenes after each death. Miller also warned that some systems are too complex for newcomers or for players who don't want to think strategically.
Which version to avoid
The PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360 versions received mixed to negative reviews. Thomas Morgan of Eurogamer called the frame rate substandard, and Yannick LeJacq of Kotaku reported many technical glitches. Stick to Windows, PlayStation 4 or Xbox One, where the critic aggregate sits at 85/100.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q15709637 wikidata.org