Shadow of the Tomb Raider's tombs are the series' best; its story is not
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Great tombs, a story critics couldn't follow
Critics praised one half of this game and criticized the other. Several called its puzzles the most sophisticated in the series, and The Verge's Sam Byford described the pacing as "excellent," with "fewer forced gun battles" than before. The story got very different reviews. The Guardian's Keza MacDonald called it an "incoherent mess," and Olivia White of The Daily Telegraph called it "incomprehensible."
That split shows in the scores. Metacritic rated the reviews as "generally favorable," though the game did less well with critics than the two earlier entries in the Survivor trilogy. The critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 7.7 out of 10.
The tombs are the reason to play
The puzzles are physics-based and come in two optional kinds. Challenge tombs are self-contained dungeons that reward a unique skill. Crypts are smaller and give outfit blueprints. PC Gamer's Andy Kelly said the tombs carry "a sense of place and scale." He also said the puzzles were never very hard but were still satisfying to solve.
Climbing ties into the puzzles. IGN's Lucy O'Brien liked the new overhang and rappel moves, and Game Informer's Kimberly Wallace noted how much the traversal tools matter in the puzzles. GameSpot's Edmond Tran was the main dissenter. Tran praised the level design but found the platforming imprecise.
Exploration, puzzles and combat each have their own difficulty setting, so a player can make the tombs harder and the fights easier, or the other way around.
Stealth beats shooting, for most critics
The game favors stealth over open fights. Lara can hide in vine walls and tall grass, cover herself in mud and fire Fear arrows that turn enemies against each other. Kelly compared the result to Batman and the Predators, and Eurogamer's Aoife Wilson said these sections treat combat "almost like a deadly puzzle."
Not every critic agreed. Tran found the combat simple and clumsy. Polygon's Ben Kuchera said the game explains its systems too much, pushes players toward one style of play and lacks "a lot of patience" for experimenting.
Lived-in hubs, half-used systems
O'Brien said the hub city of Paititi felt like a "real, lived-in city," and several reviewers enjoyed wandering the hubs as a break from the action. Her complaint was about what you actually do there: the activities were unremarkable and the side quests unimaginative. Tran said the sheer number of collectibles made the game exhausting.
The role-playing layer also drew complaints. White wrote that the game's structure doesn't support crafting and skill progression, so new upgrades often go unused. GamesRadar's Rachel Weber said these systems feel restrictive in such a linear game. The big set pieces fared better, and O'Brien called them "wonderfully orchestrated roller-coaster rides."
A Lara critics struggled to root for
The harshest reviews were about the lead character. O'Brien was an exception: she saw real growth in Lara and called the game a moving end to the trilogy. Wallace found the treatment of Lara's trauma interesting but the ending underwhelming. Most others were harsher. Tran found Lara hard to empathize with, and Wilson called the plot a "contrived revenge story" with no moments of levity.
Several critics said the violent gameplay clashed with a story that presents Lara as a flawed, human character. Some described her actions in the game as neocolonialist. Byford put both problems together, saying that the lack of new ideas in the gameplay and the weak story made it a disappointing entry in the series.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Shadow of the Tomb Raider en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q50562677 wikidata.org