Analysis · Middle-earth: Shadow of War

Shadow of War's orc army outshines its story and its sprawl

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Eight clean hits, then a finisher

Most of the game is a counter-based brawl seen from over Talion's shoulder. Each strike builds his "might" meter, and eight hits in a row open up a finisher that takes a big chunk of an enemy's health. A symbol over an orc's head warns that a parry is due. Attacks marked in red can't be blocked, so you have to dodge them. You can also take a stealthier approach to a target.

The wraith of Celebrimbor, who shares Talion's body, supplies the rest of the tools: a double jump, wraith vision that highlights nearby enemies, spirit arrows, a spectral glaive, a health drain and the power to dominate an orc. Game Informer's Matt Miller called the mix a "potent power fantasy". Leon Hurley at GamesRadar described the counter system as simple but effective and wrote that upgrades give it real depth. IGN's Dan Stapleton called Talion's traversal "quick and fun".

Eurogamer's Johnny Chiodini raised the main complaint. He felt the game hands out so many upgrade points and skills that fights get easy, and he never met a nemesis that gave him serious trouble.

The orcs are the reason to play

The nemesis system from Shadow of Mordor returns with a much bigger role. Talion can now recruit followers from several races of Middle-earth and lead them in war. Critics singled it out more than any other feature. PC Gamer's Andy Kelly called it the "best part" of the game, and Stapleton praised how it fills the world with loud, colorful orcs, each with a voice and look of its own and a habit of surprising you.

Hurley liked that any fight with an orc can grow into a small story of its own depending on your choices. He also noted that each orc's traits change how a fight plays out, so you have to improvise instead of repeating one routine. Eurogamer's Christian Donlan wrote that the system makes the world feel "wonderfully, comically, teeteringly alive".

Several critics were uneasy that building an orc army means, in effect, brainwashing and enslaving the orcs you defeat.

Sieges, gear and a very long to-do list

The game spans five regions that you can explore on foot or riding tamed beasts. Four of them hold a fortress run by an overlord. You lay siege to each one and then have to hold it, and a fortress level shows how strong its warchiefs and defenses are. Critics found the sieges epic in scale, though Stapleton wanted more room for planning and strategy.

Around that sits a lot of extra content:

  • Haedir towers to purify, which add fast travel points and reveal places of interest
  • Lost Gondorian artifacts, puzzle-locked ithildin doors and Shelob's memories to find
  • "Shadows of the Past" challenges built on Celebrimbor's memories
  • Gear in five slots (sword, dagger, bow, armor and cloak), rated common to legendary, with gems to slot and legendary sets that grant bonuses

Most of this runs on mirian, a currency you earn by defeating enemies. Kelly called the side content a "fantasy to-do list" and felt many of the systems don't fit together. Destructoid's Chris Carter found the gear too convoluted. Andrew Webster at The Verge argued that the extra content waters down the game's best moments. On top of that, critics widely criticized the microtransactions and loot boxes, which the game calls war chests.

A story even fans of the lore may resent

Talion and Celebrimbor forge a new Ring of Power to raise an army against Sauron, in a story set between Peter Jackson's Hobbit and Lord of the Rings film trilogies. Reviews of it were mostly negative. Hurley found the tone incoherent and objected to Shelob appearing as a human woman instead of a spider. Stapleton said the game plays "fast and loose" with the lore and called the dialog "clunky". Chiodini called the story "dreadful". Carter found Talion "bland", and Polygon's Phillip Kollar expected Tolkien fans to find the twists to the canon distasteful.

The smaller stories did better. GameSpot's Justin Haywald liked the quests built around side characters and orc companions but wished they lasted longer and didn't end so abruptly.

Critics were split on the look of the game. Miller called the locations a "visual treat", while Kelly saw a "sludgy, muted look". Reviewers agreed the five regions look distinct but said they bring few new enemy types. Miller also felt the progression system keeps the long campaign fresh, and that is the best case for sticking with it to the end.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet