Analysis · Shin Megami Tensei V

Shin Megami Tensei V fights brilliantly and tells its story thinly

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Critics loved the fights and shrugged at the story

The strongest praise for Shin Megami Tensei V went to its combat. GameSpot's Heidi Kemps wrote about the sense of accomplishment that comes with beating a difficult enemy, and Nintendo Life's Mitch Vogel saw the Press Turn system as a further refinement of something the series already did well. The sharpest criticism went to the story. IGN's Leana Hafer felt weak writing and shallow characters undermined a strong premise. Electronic Gaming Monthly's Mollie L. Patterson missed having a gripping story and compared it unfavorably with Nocturne.

Most reviews split the same way. Metacritic counted 84 out of 100 from 103 reviews, and the game was nominated for Best Role-Playing Game at The Game Awards 2021. The critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 8.5 out of 10.

Press Turn battles punish guessing

Your party is the Nahobino, a fusion of human and demon, plus up to three allied demons. Hitting a weakness or landing a critical hit earns an extra turn. Missing, or hitting something that voids the attack, costs one. New to this entry are Magatsuhi Skills: when the gauge fills, you can spend it without using a Press Turn to give the whole party an effect for one round, such as guaranteed critical hits or full healing. If the Nahobino dies, the game is over, however healthy the demons are.

Critics agreed the system works, though not on how much of it is new. Polygon's Diego Nicolás Argüello appreciated the additions to the core combat. Patterson felt the combat lacked truly new features.

Several reviewers said the challenge stays high even on the lower difficulty settings. Famitsu counted that difficulty balance as a strength.

The cost is time. Hafer and Game Informer's Kimberley Wallace both disliked how much grinding some areas demand before you can move forward.

Recruiting and fusing demons is the real long game

Demons join through Demon Negotiation. You answer questions based on a demon's personality, then haggle over what it wants: items, money, HP or MP. The Moon Phase changes their mood. A full moon blocks negotiation, while a new moon makes it easier. You can only recruit demons below your level, but a higher-level demon remembers a successful talk and joins once you outlevel it.

Fusion happens at Leyline Founts, which also serve as save points and shops. It combines two to four demons into a stronger one, and Reverse Fusion works backward from the demon you want. Hafer singled out the character customization this allows, and Patterson enjoyed the customization options too.

Da'at looks striking, and the Switch strains to show it

Da'at is a ruined world split into open areas, each with its own environment and enemies. The Nahobino can dash, jump and slash at objects. Exploring turns up quest-giving characters, hidden Miman that pay out an upgrade currency called Glory, and Demon Abscesses that have to be cleared before you can go further. Nintendo World Report's Donald Theriault enjoyed exploring it, but two Famitsu reviewers and Wallace had trouble finding their way around the open areas.

The art drew the warmest comments outside combat. Argüello called the demon and environment design one of the game's best features, and Kemps praised its "eerie art direction." Vogel noted that the high-definition graphics make the demons look more realistic than in earlier entries. Patterson felt the Switch's performance let all that down, and other reviewers reported frame rate drops and graphical glitches. The music and voice acting drew praise, though Wallace found the soundtrack repetitive.

A dark premise with too little holding it up

A high school student is pulled into Da'at, where angels and demons fight over who will remake the world after Lucifer kills the Creator. Moral choices and alliances decide which of several endings you reach. Famitsu liked its mix of evil and godliness, Argüello liked that it is darker than the Persona series, and Vogel liked its more character-focused take on series habits.

The complaints were more specific. Kemps noted long stretches where the plot doesn't really move. Wallace said it repeats the poor execution of earlier Shin Megami Tensei games. Theriault praised the lack of sexualization in the main cast but faulted script issues and the lack of a female playable character. A later version, Vengeance, added a new storyline that reviewers generally rated above the original's.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet