Sixteen giants in an empty land, and nothing else to fight
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A whole game built on sixteen enemies
Shadow of the Colossus rests on one idea. A game can have only sixteen enemies and still fill an open world. It has no lesser monsters, no hordes and nothing to clear between bosses. Wander, a young man trying to revive a girl named Mono, rides into a forbidden land to find and destroy sixteen colossi. That's the whole structure.
Each cycle starts at the same central point and sends you out after one colossus. Once it falls, the game returns you to that point. Critics agreed the idea worked. The game averaged 91% at GameRankings, the 11th-highest rating of 2005, and IGN rated it 9.7/10, calling it "an absolute must-have title". The critic average, computed from the critic aggregates, is 9.1 out of 10.
The empty land is doing a job
Nothing attacks you between fights, so the ride out becomes the game's quiet half. To find the next target, Wander raises his sword in sunlight, and its beams of light converge when it points the right way. The route rarely runs straight. Cliffs, ancient structures and rough ground force detours. Agro, Wander's horse, can't follow past deep water or large climbs.
The land holds only ordinary animals, and just two things in it make Wander stronger: a lizard tail that lengthens his stamina gauge and fruit that raises his maximum health. Critics read that bareness as intent. Dave Ciccoricco, a literature lecturer at the University of Otago, praised how the long rides and cutscenes push the player toward self-reflection. A later Edge retrospective credited the game with "riveting emotional power".
The music fills the space the enemies leave empty. Electronic Gaming Monthly named it Soundtrack of the Year. GameSpot said the score carried and often intensified the mood, and a Eurogamer reviewer called it "one of the finest game soundtracks ever".
Each colossus is a puzzle you climb
With so few enemies in the game, each fight has to carry a full level's worth of ideas. The first two happen on flat, open ground. There, the only question is how to climb the creature and reach its weak points, glowing sigils that the sword's light reveals. Most of the following fourteen battles also make you use the arena: water, old structures, height, or fighting from Agro's back.
Wander climbs by gripping fur and ledges while the colossus thrashes to throw him off, and his stamina gauge drains the whole time he holds on. That turns each fight into a race against your own grip. Your gear stays minimal throughout:
- a sword, which also points the way and finds weak points
- a bow and arrows
- bonus weapons, but only in subsequent playthroughs, earned through optional Time Attack trials that replay the fights against a clock
Where the idea strains
Putting everything into a handful of giant set pieces pushes the hardware hardest at the worst moments. Critics flagged an erratic frame rate that stays smooth while you cross the land and slows down during the colossus battles. GameSpot nominated it for "Most Aggravating Frame Rate" in the same awards where it was up for Best PS2 Game.
GameSpy said the camera was "as much of an opponent as the Colossi".
Reviewers were mixed on Agro's AI and controls. Edge called the controls "clumsy, crude, and unpredictable", yet IGN named Agro the best sidekick in video game history. The horse that gives the empty land its company is also its most argued-over feature.
Length is the other cost of the idea. Game Revolution and GameSpot found it too short, with an average playthrough estimated at 6 to 8 hours. Because each fight is a puzzle, it loses much of its pull once you know the answer, so replay value is thin. Sixteen is a small number, and after that the Time Attack trials are what's left.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Shadow of the Colossus en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q846051 wikidata.org