Analysis · The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword HD

Skyward Sword HD keeps its sharp dungeons and the old control fight with them

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for players who want dungeons and a story on rails

This is a Zelda for players who like a clear path, hand-built dungeons and a sword fight that asks for precision. It isn't for players who want to wander wherever they like. Skyward Sword HD is the Nintendo Switch version of the 2011 Wii game. Tantalus Media developed it, Nintendo published it, and it came out on July 16, 2021.

It sits first in the Zelda timeline and tells how the Triforce and the Master Sword came to be. Link lives on Skyloft, a town floating above the clouds. When Zelda is taken to the abandoned lands below, he goes down after her. He flies between sky islands on a Loftwing, a giant bird, and explores three surface regions on foot.

The HD release scored 81 on Metacritic, which counts as "generally favorable." Another aggregate based on 12 reviews gave it 80/100, and one Switch review gave it 7/10.

Where it delivers: fights that make direction matter

The combat is the game's clearest idea. Link's sword follows the direction of the swing, and enemies are designed to read and block his attacks. You win a fight by finding the angle a foe has left open, not by mashing. Raising the sword charges a Skyward Strike, which hits switches and enemies and opens goddess cube chests back in the sky.

Critics liked how the game was built. Even GameSpot's Tom McShea, the harshest of the major reviewers, praised the storyline, dungeons, enemies and visuals. GameTrailers singled out a believable relationship between Link and Zelda. GamesRadar's Carolyn Gudmundson called it "a perfectly balanced mix of innovation and classic Zelda gameplay." When the original came out, Famitsu, IGN, Eurogamer, Game Informer, Edge and VideoGamer.com all gave it perfect scores.

  • Dungeons mix puzzles, enemies and dedicated bosses.
  • A stamina meter limits sprinting and climbing. Run it empty and Link is left slow and exposed.
  • Dowsing switches to a first-person view and scans the area for a chosen object, so you spend less time hunting blind.

Where it doesn't: the companion, the padding and the controls

Fi is the biggest complaint. Critics and players found her constant interruptions annoying, compared her poorly to Navi from Ocarina of Time and said she hurt the pacing. Venture Beat's Sebastian Haley was the outlier and called her the best part of the game.

Pacing and structure drew complaints too. Writing for 1UP.com, Jose Otero praised the break from Zelda tradition but called the result "a weird middle ground" with "copy/paste quest structures." Some side quests on the surface are required to finish the main story. Edge disliked the upgrade system. IGN's Richard George felt the music fell short of the series' standard.

Joystiq's Griffin McElroy found much of the content unnecessary, then called what lay underneath "the best Zelda game of all time."

The controls split reviewers most. The game was designed around motion controls. Electronic Gaming Monthly's Ray Carsillo found them hard to handle and said they kept the game from greatness. McShea called them unreliable. Destructoid's Jonathan Holmes, who named it his favorite 3D Zelda, warned that relying only on motion controls would put players off. Oli Welsh of Eurogamer and VideoGamer.com's Chris Schilling praised the same controls.

What the drop from 93 to 81 says

The Wii original scored 93/100 from 81 reviews. It was Metacritic's 10th highest-scoring game of 2011 and won Game of the Year from Electronic Gaming Monthly, GameSpot, Edge and Nintendo Power. Ten years later the HD version landed 12 points lower.

That gap was already showing in 2011. GameTrailers said some mechanics marked the series' "first gray hairs." A decade on, the hand-holding, the linear layout and Fi's interruptions are harder to overlook. The dungeons and sword fights that earned the original its awards are still the reason to play.

If you mainly want to explore freely, this isn't the Zelda for you. If you want carefully designed dungeons and a story told in order, it still delivers both.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet