Analysis · The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword

Skyward Sword stakes everything on a sword that follows your arm

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Every fight is about where you swing

The whole game starts from one premise. Link's sword moves in the direction you swing the Wii Remote, and the Wii MotionPlus add-on is required to play at all. Horizontal, vertical, diagonal and a forward thrust all read as different attacks, and the shield rises when you move the Nunchuk.

That would be a gimmick if enemies ignored it. They don't. Enemies are designed to anticipate and block Link's swings, so a fight becomes a question of reading a guard and cutting around it. Raising the Remote charges a Skyward Strike, a ranged blast that also hits switches and wakes goddess cubes, which open chests back in the sky.

Critics who liked the controls liked them a lot. Eurogamer's Oli Welsh praised them outright, and VideoGamer.com's Chris Schilling listed the motion controls among the reasons it ranks with the best Zelda games. Both outlets gave it a perfect score, as did IGN, Game Informer, Edge and Famitsu.

The same idea is where critics split

Because the controls carry everything, any slip in tracking costs more here than in a game that uses buttons. That is the main fault line in the reviews.

  • Against: GameSpot's Tom McShea called the controls unreliable and gave a notably lower verdict than most. Ray Carsillo of Electronic Gaming Monthly found them hard to handle and said they kept the game from being truly great.
  • Mixed: Destructoid's Jonathan Holmes named it his new favorite 3D Zelda but warned that motion-only play would turn some people away. Game Informer's Phil Kollar and GamesRadar's Carolyn Gudmundson both loved it while noting minor control issues.

Gudmundson called it "a perfectly balanced mix of innovation and classic Zelda gameplay."

The useful read: almost nobody disliked the design of the combat. The disagreement is about whether the hardware delivered it every time.

Sky above, three regions below

Outside of fights, the structure is more traditional. Link lives on Skyloft, a floating town, and flies between sky islands on a Loftwing, a giant bird. Columns of light drop him into three surface regions where most of the adventure and its dungeons sit. A stamina meter limits sprinting and climbing, and a first-person Dowsing mode scans for whatever the story currently wants you to find.

Here the central idea matters less, and critics noticed. Jose Otero at 1UP.com credited the developers for breaking from Zelda tradition but described the result as "a weird middle ground" with "copy/paste quest structures." GameTrailers called it the series' "first gray hairs," pointing to mechanics that felt dated. Joystiq's Griffin McElroy found much of the content unnecessary, yet still called what lay beneath it "the best Zelda game of all time."

Side quests for both Skyloft residents and surface characters open up as the story moves, and some are mandatory for finishing the main quest. That is worth knowing if you prefer optional errands to stay optional.

Fi slows things down

The most consistent complaint isn't about swords at all. Fi, the spirit who guides Link, interrupts play often, and critics found those interjections annoying enough to hurt the pace. Comparisons to Navi from Ocarina of Time were not kind, and her habit of stating the obvious became an internet meme.

There was a dissenting voice. Venture Beat's Sebastian Haley found her less grating than others did and called her the best part of the game. Most players reading the reviews should still expect her to test their patience.

What the praise was really for

Strip away the control debate and the praise is broad. Critics singled out the dungeons, the enemies, the visuals (Welsh was impressed by them given the Wii's limits) and a believable relationship between Link and Zelda. IGN's Richard George praised almost everything except the soundtrack, which he felt fell short of series standards. As the first game in the Zelda timeline, it also tells the origin of the Master Sword and the Triforce, which gives longtime fans a reason to care about the story.

It holds a 93/100 on Metacritic from 81 reviews and won Game of the Year from Electronic Gaming Monthly, GameSpot, Edge and Nintendo Power. A later HD version landed lower, at 81 on Metacritic, a reminder that how well the core idea works depends heavily on how it's played.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet