Analysis · Sly Cooper and the Thievius Raccoonus

Sly Cooper's first heist is short and gentle, and critics mostly forgave it

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The argument was about length, not quality

The sharpest split over Sly Cooper and the Thievius Raccoonus was about how long it lasts. GameSpot's main complaint was that the game ends just as you settle into a groove and start enjoying the variety of its levels. The same outlet still nominated it for "Best Platformer" and for "Best Game No One Played on PlayStation 2" in its 2002 awards.

1Up.com read the same game differently. It liked the length and said the extra content stretches things out well, adding that it would happily spend about 10 more hours on it. Sucker Punch's Brian Flemming defended the length the same way, pointing to the bonus content waiting in several levels and the designer commentary earned by completing each level's Master Sprint.

Both sides describe the same thing. The story path is brief. Whether the game feels short depends on whether you count what comes after it.

Easy or old-school depends on what you came for

The second split was over difficulty. GameSpot said the game's relative ease, together with its short length, kept it from becoming "the next big platformer", though it called the game great while it lasts. Official U.S. PlayStation Magazine heard something else in the same design: a "pleasant old-school feel", with enemies that are "merciless but a bit stupid" and platforming that gets steadily harder from level to level.

The rules explain why both readings hold up. Sly goes down in a single hit, which sounds harsh. But every 100 coins earns a lucky horseshoe that absorbs a hit, and a second one turns it gold. Losing a life sends you back to the start of the sub-level or to a "repeater" checkpoint. Only losing every life sends you back to the start of a boss's lair.

The rule of thumb: if you want stealth that punishes mistakes, this isn't it. If you want stealth that teaches you and keeps you moving, it is.

What the game asks you to do

Sly works through the themed lairs of the Fiendish Five, getting past patrolling guards and security systems to recover pages of the family book, the Thievius Raccoonus. Spots marked with blue sparkles, called thief senses, show where he can shimmy along a ledge, land on an antenna, climb a pipe or grapple with his cane. That clear marking is a big part of why critics found it easy to pick up.

Get spotted and an alarm sounds. You can destroy it, deal with the guards it brings, or hide until it resets, while the adaptive music gets louder and faster and then settles once things calm down. Clue bottles in each sub-section open a safe that holds a new move, such as a decoy or an explosive hat. Bosses also hand out abilities you'll need later.

The sneaking is broken up by other modes:

  • driving levels starring Murray the Hippo
  • shooting sections where you protect Murray as he climbs
  • a cyber-tank game standing in for one of Bentley's hacks
  • a boss fight built on a rhythm sequence much like Dance Dance Revolution

The look and the feel nobody argued about

Where critics agreed, they agreed strongly. GameSpot praised a "fantastic sense of style" that ran from the animation to the cel-shaded art. IGN called Sly "incredibly responsive" and said precise jumping and fighting are a quick study, even with his long limbs and cane. Several reviewers liked how smoothly the game moves between play and cutscenes, and many said it works for adults and children alike.

The awards back this up. The Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences gave it Outstanding Achievement in Animation and in Art Direction. IGN placed it 21st in its 2008 "Top 25 PS2 Games", and GameSpy ranked it 22nd among its "25 Most Underrated Games of All Time" in 2003.

The technical complaints were minor but real: reviewers noted framerate slowdowns in later levels and some trouble with camera control.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet