Analysis · Sly Cooper: Thieves in Time

Sly Cooper's return split critics over whether old-school is a strength

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Critics agreed it plays like the early 2000s and split on whether that's good

The biggest argument about Thieves in Time wasn't about any one feature. It was about the whole approach. Sanzaru Games, which took over the series from Sucker Punch Productions, kept the old Sly Cooper formula: sneaking across hub worlds, climbing poles and ropes, picking guards' pockets and hunting optional collectibles.

One camp saw that as the point. IGN's Colin Moriarty praised it for keeping the mascot 3D platformer relevant at a time when other PlayStation series of that kind had either vanished or changed course. Reviewers at Edge and Game Informer said the familiar parts felt fresh because of how well they were mixed and varied. Official PlayStation Magazine's Robert Pearson called it a success apart from "dated boss battles" and a couple of irritating design choices.

The other camp found it repetitive and too safe. Marty Sliva was the sharpest of them, describing an open world that felt "sparse and unlived in" and a game spread across so many activities that none of them felt refined.

The split tells you more than the 77 and 71 aggregate scores do. Whether this game works for you depends on whether you want the early-2000s formula back or want it to move on.

The ancestor characters are fun to some critics and fiddly to others

The new idea in Thieves in Time is time travel. Sly visits his ancestors in different eras, and each ancestor plays a little differently. Sly also earns costumes that add abilities: armor with a shield that reflects projectiles, an archery outfit that fires rope lines, and a sword-wielding outfit that slows time. The costumes can be taken back to earlier levels to reach secret areas.

GameSpot's Tom McShea and Moriarty said the new characters kept things varied. Push Square's Sammy Barker said finding each ancestor's move gave players a reason to push on to the next world. Eurogamer's Tom Bramwell disagreed. He found the moves purely functional, without the feel of controlling Sly, and fiddly to switch between. GameRevolution's Alex Osborn called them "shallow."

Critics also couldn't agree on the balance. Osborn felt Sly still dominated the game. Bramwell felt the opposite: too little Sly platforming and too many mini-games and side sections. Even Moriarty, who liked the size of the cast, said most of the characters lacked Sly's versatility.

The writing is what most reviewers came back for

Critics were much closer to agreeing on the story and comedy. Game Informer's Matt Helgeson put the story among the best of any platform game. Moriarty called it a rare game that keeps players laughing and pointed to Murray narrating himself in the third person. Barker praised its "fun puns" compared with louder comedy in other games. McShea named the ancestor Salim as the funniest character.

There were exceptions. Edge didn't find the script funny but still credited its plot twists with a ramshackle charm. Osborn was the main critic of the writing and called the dialogue "forced and played out." VentureBeat's Stephanie Carmichael liked the voice acting but felt Bentley and Murray gave away too many solutions.

Critics also praised the bright, varied eras and the cartoon cutscenes. Sliva disagreed about the layouts, calling them "bland" and samey.

Where the friction shows up

  • Controls: you still jump and then press circle to latch onto things. Moriarty called this "archaic" and Osborn called it "clunky," and Osborn added that the button prompt sometimes sits in a hard-to-spot corner of the screen.
  • Bosses: Carmichael and McShea enjoyed how hard they are, but Pearson found them frustrating. Several critics said they lean too heavily on patterns, and Carmichael called the last boss anti-climactic.
  • Murray and Bentley sections: McShea and Pearson both said Murray's sections come down to punching over and over. Pearson didn't like Bentley's either.
  • Difficulty: McShea felt the game puts freedom of movement ahead of challenge, especially early on.

On the other side, critics said the campaign runs about 20 hours, with more time on top for optional collectibles. McShea called that scavenging the best part of the game. Anyone who owns both the PlayStation 3 and PlayStation Vita versions can use the Vita as augmented-reality "x-ray goggles" for finding hidden items.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet