Analysis · Super Smash Bros. for Wii U

Smash on Wii U is the series at its fullest, until you take it online

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for a full couch and a long memory of Nintendo

This is a game for the friend who brings extra controllers. It's a multiplayer platform fighter. You don't drain an opponent's health bar. You build up their damage percentage until one hit sends them flying off the stage. Items keep matches unpredictable. A Smash Ball gives a character its Final Smash, and an Assist Trophy calls in a non-playable character to fight for you.

It also speaks to longtime Nintendo players. Jose Otero at IGN praised how it appeals to "the nostalgia of long-time Nintendo fans" while still being "accessible to new players." Both groups can share the same match, and that's the point of the design.

Where it delivers: more ways to play than anyone needed

Critics singled out the variety of modes, and the list backs them up:

  • Omega stages: every stage has a flat, hazard-free version with ledges on both sides, so players who want a clean fight can have one anywhere.
  • For Glory: an online mode against strangers with no items, stock matches only, Omega stages only, and both standard and 1-on-1 battles, with every win and loss recorded.
  • For Fun: the opposite, with random stages, items and timed matches.
  • Classic mode: you can spend in-game currency to raise the difficulty and earn bigger rewards.
  • Home-Run Contest and Target Blast: the first returns with a competitive version for up to four players, and the second has you beat up a ticking bomb and launch it into targets for chain reactions.

Daniel Bischoff of GameRevolution called it "the biggest leap forward" the series had made and praised its "incredibly fast action." Thomas Schulenberg of Joystiq pointed to its "abundance of goals to chase," which fits a game packed with collectible trophies and rewards.

Where it doesn't: playing with strangers online

The complaints cluster in one place. Daniel Starkey at GameSpot called the game "incredible" but criticized its inconsistent online performance. Schulenberg at Joystiq described matches "plagued with stuttering frame rates" during online play.

That matters most to the competitive player that For Glory was built for. A ranked-style mode loses its appeal when the frame rate can't be trusted. Locally, with everyone on the same screen, that problem doesn't come up.

Online play with strangers also blocks some of the game's new features. Customized characters, Mii Fighters and Amiibo can't be used there, so any time spent tuning a fighter's moves only pays off with friends or offline.

The extras are a mixed bag

New to the series, you can customize existing characters and build your own Mii Fighters with altered attacks and power-ups. You can move them between the Wii U and 3DS versions. You can also use Amiibo figures to train computer-controlled fighters and bring them into a match.

Not every critic cared. Schulenberg admitted to "indifference toward the Amiibo experience." Treat it as a side feature, not a reason to buy.

The Wii U version leans on stages and trophies from home console games, while the 3DS version draws mainly on handheld titles. Critics also credited it with improving on the 3DS release. The small-screen complaints and the thin single-player modes that reviewers raised about the 3DS version were part of that comparison.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet