Sniper Elite 5 builds its best levels yet around a familiar formula
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Best in the series, or a better Sniper Elite 4
Eurogamer called Sniper Elite 5 "a true great of the genre" and one of the most entertaining games of its year. IGN saw something smaller: "more of an incremental upgrade rather than a major revolution," with objectives repeated so often that the campaign started to feel repetitive.
Both critics are describing the same game. It's a third-person tactical shooter set in France during World War II, built from a handful of large levels like the ones in Sniper Elite 4. It sticks close to that game and polishes it. Aggregate critic scores sit between 74 and 79 out of 100, and the critic average, computed from those aggregates, is 7.7. That fits a game most reviewers liked a lot without many calling it a surprise.
The levels earn most of the praise
The maps got the most consistent praise. EGM pointed to the "intricate" level design, and Hardcore Gamer called it "some of the series' best." Eurogamer liked how flexible the sandboxes are. Each level offers several ways in and several ways out, so you choose where to set up, which guards to avoid and when to start shooting.
GameSpot said the game rewards that freedom and treats your choices as the point. Several critics named one mission, "Spy Academy," as the high point of the campaign. Hardcore Gamer also credited the visual variety from one map to the next for keeping the campaign from blurring together, even though IGN felt the objectives inside those maps kept repeating.
Guns you can tune and an X-ray camera that shows the damage
Sniping is the core of the game, and GameSpot said its strengths start there. On a long-range rifle kill, the X-Ray kill cam follows the bullet to the target and shows bones and organs breaking as it hits. Shacknews, which gave the game 9 out of 10, praised the detail in those shots and said the guns "feel responsive."
Weapon customization goes deep. EGM and GameSpot both counted it among the game's main strengths, because you can rebuild a rifle to suit how you want to approach a level. Expect the kill cam to be graphic: the game is rated Mature 17+ and PEGI 16, and the X-ray shots are a big part of the reason.
Axis Invasion is the biggest new idea
The most important addition is Invasion mode, which reviewers also called Axis Invasion. A third player can join your session as an enemy sniper and hunt you while you work through the mission. GamesRadar+ said this mode is what puts the game ahead of earlier entries. Hardcore Gamer called it "the best thing" about the game, and GameSpot described the invasions as tense.
- Co-op campaign: a second player can join you for the whole single-player story.
- Invasion: a third player can enter as an enemy sniper.
- Survival: a separate mode for up to four players.
With these modes, a campaign that IGN found repetitive becomes less predictable, because another person may be watching the same rooftops you are.
Where critics agreed it falls short
The complaints were consistent. EGM called the characters and story underdeveloped, and IGN agreed while also faulting the enemy AI. GamesRadar+ said the series' long-standing weaknesses are still there next to its strengths. Shacknews, despite its high score, criticized the PC performance and the dated facial animations.
Come for the maps and the rifles. Few critics found the plot or the people in it worth staying for.
None of these problems affect what the game does best, but they set a limit on how good it can be. If you want a strong war story or smart enemies, critics' accounts suggest this game won't give you either.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Sniper Elite 5 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q63464391 wikidata.org