Analysis · Mario & Sonic at the Sochi 2014 Olympic Winter Games

Sochi 2014 puts Mario and Sonic on ice with motion controls critics fought

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Every event depends on how well the controls respond

The basic loop is simple. You pick one of twenty characters, all returning from the previous two games, and compete across sixteen Olympic events. Depending on the event, you play with the Wii Remote (Plus), the Nunchuk or the Wii U GamePad. Some events, like the biathlon, use both control methods.

Skiing, bobsledding and curling come back from earlier games. The new events are figure skating pairs and snowboarding slope style. Because the roster is made up entirely of returning characters, the new events and modes have to carry most of the freshness.

The controls drew the most criticism. Critics singled out the motion controls as a weak point, and IGN's Scott Thompson was the harshest. He gave the game 4.5 out of 10 and said its good ideas were weighed down by "bad motion controls". In a game made almost entirely of short, physical mini-games, unresponsive input hurts every event.

Dream Events and a quiz tour add variety but not depth

Beyond the real Olympic events, there are eight fictional Dream Events set in places from the Mario and Sonic games. One of them is a new mixed event where snowboarders, skiers and bobsledders compete at the same time. It's the clearest case of the crossover idea doing something real winter sports can't.

The other new mode is the Action & Answer Tour. Players answer questions to score points while competing in events, with Orbot and Cubot from Sonic Colors and Sonic Lost World as hosts. It mixes trivia and sport, which suits a living room full of players of different skill levels.

The GamePad features got a cooler response. Nintendo Life's Gaz Plant called the GamePad's TV idea inventive but said it is "never taken far enough". The ideas are there, but they feel unfinished.

It looks the part and works best with a crowd

Most critics praised the presentation. Digital Spy's Liam Martin gave it 3 out of 5 and called it a flashy, fun mini-game collection for the whole family when the action gets going. He also said it lacks "spark", and that complaint echoes through the reviews.

Multiplayer is where reviewers had the most fun. Both Nintendo Life and Digital Spy said a group of friends gets the most out of it, and the game is rated Everyone and PEGI 3, so the whole family can play. Critics welcomed the online mode, though Nintendo Life called it "too limited" to stand on its own.

Why it feels like a rerun

The biggest problem is how long it stays interesting. Nintendo Life scored it 6 out of 10 and called it a minor step forward that takes many of its cues from the 2010 game. Plant felt it skipped the rapid-fire party style of the 2012 game and hits the same unremarkable buttons as four years earlier.

Nintendo Life's take: with friends there's still fun here, but it's hard to shake the feeling you've done it all before.

The scores reflect that:

  • Nintendo Life: 6 out of 10
  • Digital Spy: 3 out of 5
  • IGN: 4.5 out of 10
  • Metacritic: 55/100

The critic average of 5.6, computed from critic aggregates, lands in the same place. If you already own an earlier winter entry in the series, there's little new here besides two events, the quiz tour and limited online play. If this would be your first one, those gaps matter less.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet