Sonic and the Secret Rings shines at full speed and stumbles when it slows
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The split is over levels that make Sonic slow down
Critics mostly agreed that Secret Rings improved on the recent Sonic games. Where they parted ways was the level design, and that split tells you most about who will enjoy it.
GameSpy's Patrick Joynt liked the fast stages and felt the ones that made players "move carefully" dragged the game down. IGN's Matt Casamassina praised the variety of missions and how different each level looks, but faulted where obstacles were placed. Eurogamer's Rob Fahey went further, criticizing "leaps of faith" and blind spots that could have been avoided.
The core of it is that Secret Rings is built for momentum. Sonic runs along a set path, and the player steers, jumps and brakes. When a mission keeps that flow going, critics were happy. When it asks for precision on a route you can't fully see, the design works against itself.
Eight levels stretched across 110 missions
The game has 110 missions, boss battles included, spread over eight levels. That means each stage gets reused many times with different objectives. Fahey found that reuse "a little bit disconcerting", but he also admitted it adds replay value and compared the stages to tracks in a racing game.
That comparison is a useful test. If you like running the same course over and over to shave seconds and learn every turn, the repetition is the point. If you want new scenery around every corner, it will wear thin.
There are no lives and no game over screen. Sonic goes back to the last checkpoint when he dies, though failing a mission's goal restarts the mission. That keeps frustration lower than in older Sonic games, even on the stages critics disliked.
Tilt controls ask for patience first
Sonic is controlled only with the Wii Remote held sideways. Tilting it steers, the face buttons jump and brake, and thrusting the remote forward sets off the homing attack.
1UP.com's Shane Bettenhausen called the controls "a tad reckless at first", saying Sonic's momentum takes time to get used to and that going backward is a pain. He added that they become more natural once you adjust, and Casamassina and GameSpot's Greg Mueller felt much the same. Empire was less forgiving and flagged "sluggish controls" and an erratic camera. Nintendo Power's Chris Shepperd disliked the low camera angle and the targeting system.
The pattern across reviews: the controls feel rough early and better later, but the camera never fully won critics over.
A skill system that rewards sticking with it
Finishing missions earns experience points, and leveling up gives Sonic new skills. There are 104 of them, sorted into four Skill Rings that you pick before each mission. Many run on the Soul Gauge, which fills as Sonic collects pearls.
- Speed Break gives a big burst of speed.
- Time Break slows time so obstacles are easier to dodge.
This gives the repeated levels a reason to exist: a stage that felt unfair early can play differently with the right skill set. The Special Book mode adds 225 bonuses, including concept art, music and development interviews, earned by finishing levels fast and collecting Fire Souls.
Treat the party mode as an extra
Party mode lets up to four players compete in turn-based motion-control minigames. Bettenhausen saw it as a failed take on Mario Party, and Fahey called the minigames "lame", saying a racing mode would have been better. Casamassina was kinder, saying only a few stand out but players would still be glad to have them. Shepperd complained that some of the best party features require heavy play of the story first.
Don't buy this for game night. The single-player Adventure mode is the reason to play.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Sonic and the Secret Rings en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q1633714 wikidata.org