Sonic Colors builds its best ideas on eight colors of alien power-ups
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The Wisps are the reason this game exists
Sonic Colors is a speed platformer built around the Wisps, an alien race that Doctor Eggman has enslaved inside his Incredible Interstellar Amusement Park. Free a Wisp and Sonic borrows its power for a moment. There are eight types, and each color does something different.
- Cyan Laser turns Sonic into a beam that bounces off surfaces and travels through power lines.
- Yellow Drill digs through soft ground and water.
- Orange Rocket launches him straight up to great heights.
- Pink Spikes lets him stick to walls and ceilings.
- Purple Frenzy turns him into a creature that eats everything in its path and grows as it goes.
Critics agreed that this was the right idea. Matthew Keast of GamesRadar called the Wisps the game's best feature. Tim Turi of Game Informer said they added a new mechanic "without succumbing to Werehog-itis". Arthur Gies of IGN compared them to the power-ups in the Super Mario games but still found Colors distinctive and fresh.
Going back to old levels is where the idea pays off
The game has five small planets. Each has six acts and a boss, and a seventh planet ends the story. Every act is graded from S down to D. That setup alone gives you a reason to replay a level, but the Wisps add a better one.
New Wisp types turn up as you progress, so earlier levels hold routes you couldn't reach the first time. Keast called this backtracking clever, and reviewers named replay value as one of the game's strengths. If the Wisps were only a gimmick, there'd be no reason to return. Because they open new paths, a finished level becomes a level worth playing again.
The plain running holds up without the power-ups
A power-up idea only works if the base game is solid, and most critics said it was. Al Bickham of Eurogamer praised how the game weaves platforming and speed together, along with its use of the Wii Remote. Sonic keeps his boost, homing attack and stomp, and gains a double jump. Some stretches ask for quick steps around walls and drifts through sharp turns.
The camera moves between side-scrolling and third-person views. Gies, Jane Douglas of GameSpot and John Meyer of Wired all praised this, and Meyer called it "elegant and cohesive". Douglas went a step further and preferred the basic platforming to the Wisps. That's a minority view on the main idea, but it shows that the running itself is strong.
Where the idea runs out: difficulty, bosses and co-op
The most common complaint had nothing to do with the Wisps. Gies, Pedro Hernandez of Nintendo World Report, Meyer, Turi and Keast all called the game too hard, and Keast described it as "hardcore". Sonic starts with a limited number of lives, and when they run out the game ends.
The parts without Wisps drew the most criticism. Douglas found the boss fights repetitive. Both Gies and Douglas disliked the co-op mode, Eggman's Sonic Simulator, and Douglas called it "ugly" and the multiplayer weak.
One critic disagreed with nearly everyone. Writing for Destructoid, James Stephanie Sterling called the game "terribly designed" and faulted its controls and physics for repeating the series' old problems.
A good-looking park to throw the Wisps around in
The presentation got some of the warmest praise. Hernandez called the graphics "gorgeous", and Gies counted them among the best on the Wii because of their lighting, detail and variety. Douglas liked the "jazzy, high-energy" soundtrack, and both Douglas and Hernandez enjoyed its nods to earlier Sonic games. The new voice cast went over well too. Gies found them much less annoying than the previous actors.
"Wii owners shouldn't miss an opportunity to play with Sonic at his best," wrote Jane Douglas of GameSpot.
Other outlets went just as far. IGN named it one of the best games on the Wii, and Empire called it a return to form after a run of poorly received entries such as the 2006 reboot. The one critic score on file is an 8/10 for the Wii version, which gives a critic average of 8.0 from that single review.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Sonic Colors en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q151614 wikidata.org