Analysis · Sonic Free Riders

Sonic Free Riders buries a full Riders racer under exhausting Kinect controls

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Your body is the only controller, and that's the problem

Every race in Sonic Free Riders is played standing up. You lean your body to steer your hoverboard, make kicking motions to pick up speed and jump to pull off tricks that earn boost. Some races put you on a bike instead, which you steer with your hands. There's no gamepad fallback. The game works only with the Kinect.

Power-ups and weapons each have their own gesture. You throw a missile like a football, and you trigger one boost by shaking an imaginary soda can. On paper that's playful. In reviews, it's where most of the trouble started.

Many critics said the motion controls ruined the game and made it a poor Kinect launch title. GameTrailers scored it 4.5, calling the controls cumbersome and physically draining. Joystiq gave it 1 star out of 5 and compared it to patting your head and rubbing your stomach while "riding a unicycle." Kotaku's Brian Crecente called it "the most broken" of the Kinect games he had played.

Crecente later reported that the controls seemed to respond differently from person to person: fellow Kotaku reviewer Stephen Totilo said they worked fine for him.

That split matters. Even the friendlier reviews mentioned problems. Official Xbox Magazine noted the controls were occasionally unresponsive, and IGN said they "make it hard to just jump into the game." Whether the game works for you may come down to your body, your room and how patient you are.

A real Sonic Riders racer sits underneath

Strip away the gestures and this is a proper entry in the series, not a stripped-down motion-control demo. Collecting rings raises your level during each race and improves your character's stats, so a clean line through the course pays off as the race goes on.

Characters still fall into Speed, Flight and Power classes, and each class can take its own shortcuts. You can also give your Gear special attributes, such as sharper cornering or the ability to break through barriers, and change between them by switching your riding stance. If you fall behind, special moves give you a way to catch up.

That's a lot of systems to manage with your whole body at once. It also explains the Joystiq comparison: steering, kicking, tricking, switching stances and gesturing for items all compete for the same arms and legs.

Plenty of modes, little story

The main single-player mode is Grand Prix. You pick one of four teams and race through a story about a World Grand Prix run by a disguised Doctor Eggman, who is secretly collecting data from the racers to program into his robots. Earlier Sonic Riders games told their stories with CGI and in-game cutscenes. This one uses static character art and short exchanges of dialogue between races, in a more arcade-style format.

Beyond Grand Prix, the game offers:

  • Time Attack and Free Race for solo play.
  • Tag Mode, where two players race together and have to time their moves to pull off combined tricks.
  • Relay, for up to 4 players, with teammates swapping in after each lap.
  • Online races for up to eight players, one per console.

Local play allows only two active players at a time. You can also move through the menus with voice commands.

This breadth is where the game earned its praise. Official Xbox Magazine gave it 7.5 for its content and multiplayer options, and some critics also liked the graphics and the story.

How it has aged

Metacritic lists the reception as "generally unfavorable," and Common Sense Media gave it two stars out of five for its control problems. In 2023, fans released a mod that replaced the Kinect with ordinary button controls. That tells you where the community thinks the game's problem lies.

Free Riders was also the last Sonic racer with Extreme Gear for a long time. The hoverboards didn't come back until Sonic Racing: CrossWorlds in 2025, which offers them as a vehicle choice. For anyone who wants hoverboard racing without having to flail at a camera, the earlier Sonic Riders games and CrossWorlds are the better places to look.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet