Analysis · Sonic and the Black Knight

Sonic trades speed for a sword, and the swing lags behind the wrist

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The last Storybook game, and the only Sonic without Eggman

Sonic Team released Sonic and the Black Knight on the Wii in March 2009 as the second and final entry in the Sonic Storybook sub-series. It follows Sonic and the Secret Rings (2007), which took Sonic into a storybook world. This time the book is the legend of King Arthur. The wizard Merlina pulls Sonic into the story to stop what she says is a corrupted Arthur. Later it turns out Arthur was never corrupted, and Sonic has to stop Merlina's misguided attempt to keep the legend's fate from happening.

It also stands alone in the wider series. It's the first and only Sonic game with no Dr. Eggman at all. That's a bold change for a franchise built on one rivalry, and the King Arthur twist gives the plot more room than a robot-smashing excuse would.

What it kept from Secret Rings

The skeleton is the same. Sonic still runs forward on his own along a set path. You can strafe left or right and backflip to go back, but you don't steer freely through open levels. Most stages are in 3D, and some switch to a fixed 2D plane where you can only move left or right.

The big change in control is that movement now goes through the Nunchuck's analog stick, while the Wii Remote handles attacks and dodges. That splits the work in a sensible way: thumb for direction, arm for combat.

What it added: a sword, a forge and a roster

Sonic now carries Caliburn, a sword you swing by moving the Wii Remote, both to attack and to defend. The familiar Sonic items come back as fairies:

  • Yellow fairies give one to twenty rings.
  • Blue fairies raise speed and jump height.
  • Red fairies fill the Soul Gauge, which powers a homing Soul Surge attack.

Higher stage ranks earn better rewards, and Tails, cast as the blacksmith, turns them into new or upgraded equipment. Sonic starts in a balanced Knight style and later gets the faster Cavalier and the heavier Paladin.

The cast grows too. Knuckles plays as Sir Gawain, with twin swords that work as boomerangs and the ability to glide. Shadow is Sir Lancelot and uses Chaos Powers. Blaze plays Percival, wrapping herself in fire and lunging more often than Sonic does. These knights can switch swords in story mode, which Sonic can't, but they can't use the extra styles. Multiplayer minigames add eight more characters on top of those.

Where critics drew the line: the swing

Reviewers agreed on the presentation. IGN's Matt Casamassina praised the visuals and overall presentation. Chris Scullion of the UK's Official Nintendo Magazine liked both the visuals and the soundtrack. GameDaily credited its "attractive presentation" and bonus content.

The trouble came once the sword was in hand. Casamassina called the gameplay "broken" and the controls "unresponsive". GameSpot's Carolyn Petit put her finger on the cause: the sword clears enemies well enough, but there's a noticeable delay between swinging the Wii Remote and Sonic swinging on screen. In a game about speed, that lag hits hardest. GameDaily added repetitive combat, easy missions and limited controls to the list, and Scullion also criticized the multiplayer.

1Up.com's Sam Kennedy gave it a C+ and summed up the trade: classic Sonic play swapped for "overly simple swordplay".

Kennedy did think younger fans would enjoy it. Videogamer.com, which gave it 5 out of 10, wasn't so forgiving: aiming for a mainstream audience, it said, doesn't excuse "shoddy gameplay". Metacritic lists the reception as "mixed or average", and GameRankings put it at 55%.

The bottom line on what changed

Black Knight fixed the right things around the edges. Analog movement, a crafting loop, unlockable styles and more playable characters give it more depth than its predecessor's on-rails setup. What it didn't fix was the gap between motion input and on-screen action, and this time that gap sits in the one verb you use most. If you can put up with the delay, the extra systems are there. Critics mostly found they couldn't.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet