Sony's 2015 baseball game scored near 80 everywhere but the Vita
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
One baseball season built for three PlayStation machines
MLB 15: The Show is built on one idea: a single yearly baseball game from San Diego Studio, released on March 31, 2015, on PlayStation 4, PlayStation 3 and PlayStation Vita at the same time. It's the tenth entry in the MLB: The Show series, published by Sony, with both single-player and multiplayer modes.
That spread is the right test for it. A sports game that ships on a new console, an older one and a handheld promises the same season on all three. If the idea holds, the version you own shouldn't change much about the verdict. Critics wrote little about specific modes or mechanics, so the clearest evidence is how each version scored and where the scores split.
On PS4 and PS3, critics landed around 80
Reviews were "generally favorable." The PlayStation 4 version averaged 81% on GameRankings across 29 reviews and 80/100 on Metacritic across 37. One aggregate of nine reviews scored the PS4 and PS3 versions the same, at 81/100 each. A separate aggregate of 33 reviews, dated June 2, 2015, also landed at 80/100.
The matching PS3 number matters. Critics didn't treat the older console's version as a lesser game, so the three-platform idea worked on the home consoles. The critic average, computed from these critic aggregates, is 8.1 out of 10.
The Vita version is where the idea strains
The handheld version holds 71% on GameRankings, about 10 points below the PS4 version. That's still a passing grade, but it's the clearest sign that the game didn't land equally on every machine. A 10-point gap is the difference between a strong recommendation and a cautious one.
It's also the end of the line. MLB 15 was the last game in the series released for the PlayStation Vita. If you want The Show on that handheld, this is the newest version you can get, and critics rated it a step down from the console versions.
The headline feature depends on servers
Sony held back review copies until launch day. A Sony representative said the delay was "due to this year's flagship Universal Rewards feature," which would "require active servers to function." Copies went out on the public release date, March 31.
Two things follow from that. Critics couldn't publish before buyers had the game, so the reviews arrived after launch. And the feature Sony called its flagship was designed to rely on online servers, so it's only worth as much as the servers behind it, whatever is on the disc.
A feature that needs active servers to function works only as long as those servers are running.
It was nominated as one of the year's best sports games
The Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences nominated MLB 15: The Show for Sports Game of the Year at the 19th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards. With scores near 80 on the home consoles, that puts it among the better-regarded sports games of its year. That's a strong showing for a yearly sports release.
The thing to remember is that the version you buy matters. On PS4 or PS3 you get the game critics scored around 80. On Vita you get the one they scored 71.
Sources
- Wikipedia: MLB 15: The Show en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q18920958 wikidata.org