Soulstorm adds fliers and two factions but plays Dark Crusade's campaign again
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A third expansion from a new hand
Soulstorm is the third expansion to Warhammer 40,000: Dawn of War, the real-time strategy game based on Games Workshop's tabletop wargame. It came out on March 4, 2008, for Microsoft Windows, published by THQ and developed by Iron Lore Entertainment, the studio behind the action RPG Titan Quest and its expansion Immortal Throne.
That background matters, because Iron Lore's job here was to extend the series, not reinvent it. It held to that brief closely, and the critic reaction follows from that. Reviewers mostly agreed the expansion is competent. Where they split was on whether competent was enough for a third trip back.
What changed: fliers and two new armies
The biggest addition is an aerial unit for every faction, built to take down vehicles and structures. GameSpot and IGN both counted the fliers among the expansion's strengths, along with its setting and atmosphere.
The two new playable factions are the Imperial Sisters of Battle and the Dark Eldar. Critics disagreed about them more than anything else:
- GameSpot and IGN praised them as worthwhile additions.
- GameRevolution called the new factions uninteresting.
- Eurogamer said Soulstorm lacks the "massively appealing races" of earlier expansions.
Soulstorm is a stand-alone install, but there's a catch. To play any faction other than the two new ones in multiplayer, you need the earlier games installed and valid CD keys for them. So Soulstorm works as an add-on for existing owners, not as a starting point.
What it kept: Dark Crusade's map, minus your bases
As in Dark Crusade, the campaign is a Risk-style map, this time with 31 territories spread across four planets and three moons. You take provinces, fight battles on them, and absorb a rival faction's unique passive ability once you capture its stronghold and knock it out of the campaign.
Two changes make the campaign play differently:
- Bases no longer persist. Whatever you build on a conquered territory is gone in later fights, apart from buildings bought as reinforcements. The Sisters of Battle get a passive ability that adds a forward base when attacking.
- Enemy strength depends on army size, not on the strength of the province the attack comes from.
Those are real tweaks, but critics didn't think they were enough. GameSpot and IGN both criticized the lack of innovation and said the campaign feels the same as Dark Crusade's. GamesRadar called the campaign weak outright. Losing your bases also removes some of the sense of building something across the map, though none of the cited critics singled that out as the problem.
Multiplayer and the aging engine
Multiplayer is unchanged from earlier games, over LAN or the GameSpy network, and critics liked it. GamesRadar called it solid and approved of the balance changes. GameRevolution praised the number of maps, the amount of single-player content and the steady performance.
A new medal system rewards milestones such as a 5-to-1 kill ratio. At launch, though, there was no way to see your full medal collection, and a bug kept some players from joining online games.
The engine was the common complaint. Several outlets mentioned how old it looked. Eurogamer still called the series "thrilling, explosive" strategy but said it was starting to look "quite raggedy," and gave the expansion 6 out of 10.
Eurogamer's summary fits most of the reviews: the game underneath is still good, and Soulstorm "offers too little" on top of it.
Across 14 counted reviews, the critic aggregate was 70/100, which Metacritic labels "mixed or average."
Sources
- Wikipedia: Warhammer 40,000: Dawn of War – Soulstorm en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q1367520 wikidata.org