Analysis · Spider-Man

Spider-Man's web-swinging won over every critic, its open world won far fewer

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Critics split hardest on the missions where Spider-Man steps aside

The sharpest disagreement over Spider-Man came from the stretches where Peter isn't in control. Some story missions switch to Mary Jane Watson or Miles Morales. Neither can swing or fight like Spider-Man, so they sneak instead. Game Informer said these sections "bring variety in fun ways," with solid stealth and clever puzzles. GameSpot found them undemanding but credited them with "some memorably tense scenarios." VideoGamer.com went the other way, calling them "a bit hit-and-miss" and at times grating.

That split is a useful test of whether the game suits you. If a slower, puzzle-minded change of pace sounds like a welcome break between big set pieces, these missions will probably land. If the whole appeal is being Spider-Man, they'll feel like the game holding you back.

Combat is fast and flexible, but maybe not deep

The same divide runs through the fighting. Combat uses three buttons: dodge, strike and web attack. On top of that come gadgets, objects to throw and enemy types that each need a different answer. Shielded enemies have to be hit from behind, and enemies with melee weapons have to be knocked into the air first. Whip users pull Spider-Man out of the air unless he counters. A white spider-sense icon warns of incoming attacks, and a well-timed dodge sets up a web counter.

Critics praised the speed and flow. Game Revolution ranked it among the best combat they had played, and IGN said that once more abilities open up, fights leave real room for improvising. EGMNOW agreed there were plenty of options but found little depth underneath. It also disliked how the radial gadget menu broke the flow. USGamer liked the range of gadgets enough to reject comparisons with the Batman: Arkham series, though it found that auto-lock often picked the wrong target in large groups.

Players who like mixing tools on the fly will get the most out of it. Anyone who wants a fighting system that keeps rewarding mastery may hit the ceiling EGMNOW described.

Nobody argued about the swinging

Web-swinging is where the arguments stop: reviewers praised it without exception. Each web has to attach to a building or another object, and letting go at the right moment trades speed for height, so you manage your own momentum. EGMNOW called it a streamlined take on the physics-based swinging in Spider-Man 2 (2004). GameRevolution praised how well it conveys speed. Game Informer said it was fun enough that they never used the subway fast-travel system. On Windows, PC Gamer found mouse and keyboard as good as the controller, and in some cases better.

IGN described swinging past Manhattan's glass towers at dusk as some of the calmest, most "zen-like" play it had found in a while. GamesRadar+ called it "a lovely looking game" all the way through the final story moments. IGN's one visual complaint was that minor characters' faces fall well short of the main cast's.

The open world is built from parts critics had seen before

The most consistent criticism was aimed at the map, not the hero. Reviewers said the open world falls back on habits from earlier free-roaming games:

  • towers that reveal parts of the map and mark waypoints;
  • collectible hunts with little variety;
  • side activities that Game Revolution found monotonous after a short while.

EGMNOW said it puts up with side content better than most critics, yet still found too much of it here. Both EGMNOW and VideoGamer.com rated the side missions below the main story, and VideoGamer.com called many of them unnecessary to the plot.

This content also pays for upgrades. Suits, suit mods and gadgets are bought with Tokens, which you earn by finishing specific tasks. Completionists will find plenty to chase. Players who only want the story can skip much of it and still see the parts critics liked best.

A Peter Parker story critics took seriously

The story came closest to universal praise after the swinging. The crime lord Mister Negative moves to take over New York's criminal underworld and threatens to release a deadly virus, while Peter Parker struggles with his life outside the mask. USGamer called the story the game's best part. IGN noted a slow start but praised the focus on Peter and Yuri Lowenthal's "emotional honesty" in the role. EGMNOW said the game understands Peter better than almost any comic adaptation. Some critics were glad it skips the origin story.

IGN's main reservation was about pacing. It called the boss fights big and tense, but said they're bunched at the start and end, leaving a long middle without them.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet