Analysis · Splatoon 2

Splatoon 2 sharpens its ink fights but puts its best mode on a timer

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Ink is your ammo, your cover and your road

You play as Inklings or Octolings, squid-like characters who shoot colored ink to paint the arena. In humanoid form you walk and fire. In cephalopod form you swim fast through ink of your own color, hide in it and refill your tank. Painting the ground is how you attack, how you move and how you reload.

Each main weapon comes with a set loadout: one sub weapon, which costs ink and is usually a projectile or a defensive structure, and one special weapon that charges as you cover the ground. Cosmetic gear can carry abilities such as faster swimming or a bigger ink tank.

Seven of the nine main weapon classes return from Splatoon, among them rifle-like Shooters, sniper-style Chargers, paint-rolling Rollers and Splatlings, which work like Gatling guns. Two are new:

  • Dualies, a pair of guns that let you dodge roll.
  • Brellas, shotgun-like umbrellas that fold open into a shield.

Critics mostly liked the rebalancing. Gabe Gurwin of Digital Trends said the reworked arenas suit several weapon classes, and Brian Shea of Game Informer thought the weapon changes made them more versatile. Rokurou Eyama of Automaton was less sure: some Splatoon weapons were too strong and needed toning down, but he worried the changes could leave play feeling "stale."

Short matches, rotating rules

Turf War is the core mode: two teams of four, three minutes, and whichever side has inked more of the map wins. At level 10, Ranked Battles open up. These last five minutes plus any overtime, and the mode on offer changes through the day:

  • Splat Zones: hold an area by keeping it covered in your ink.
  • Tower Control: ride a moving tower through checkpoints into the enemy base.
  • Rainmaker: carry a heavy weapon to the other team's base.
  • Clam Blitz: new here. Collect clams, turn 10 into a Power Clam to break open the enemy goal, then score.

League Battles add a tournament-style version of Ranked. Critics found Turf War and Ranked as fun as they were in the first game, though some objected that stages still rotate on a timer.

Salmon Run is the standout, when it's open

Critics picked Salmon Run, the new co-op mode, as the game's best addition and praised how hard it is and how much it depends on teamwork. They were just as unhappy that it's only available at certain times. Brian Shea called the limit "baffling and frustrating," and Neal Ronaghan of Nintendo World Report called it "downright awful."

The single-player campaign also did well with critics, who found its levels mechanically engaging and a step up from the first game's. Mollie L. Patterson of Electronic Gaming Monthly liked Off the Hook, the new host duo, for their chemistry and their songs. A paid single-player expansion, Octo Expansion, came out on June 16, 2018.

The friction is outside the matches

Voice chat is the most common complaint. It only works through the Nintendo Switch Online smartphone app. Andrew Webster of The Verge and Kallie Plagge of GameSpot said this makes playing with friends needlessly complicated. Brittany Vincent of Game Revolution and Will Greenwald of PCMag found setting up lobbies in the app clumsy. IGN's Brendan Graeber pointed out that your phone has to stay on for the conversation to continue.

Matchmaking drew complaints too. At launch you couldn't change your weapon loadout between matches, which Alex Olney of Nintendo Life called "genuinely frustrating." Sam Machkovech of Ars Technica and Samuel Horti of GamesRadar+ both disliked that you couldn't back out of the matchmaking menu yourself.

A sharper Splatoon rather than a new one

Critics agreed the game looks better than Splatoon and mostly credited the Switch's stronger hardware. The bigger question was ambition. Horti felt the series' formula hadn't really changed, and Ronaghan and Patterson both said it felt "more like Splatoon 1.5."

If you never played the first game, that criticism barely matters. If you did, Salmon Run, Clam Blitz and the two new weapon classes are the reasons to come back.

The game's staying power rests on short matches, rotating rules and a ranked ladder, and it was still well regarded at the end of its release year. Eurogamer put it 17th in its top 50 games of 2017, and Polygon ranked it 43rd in its best 50. Its critic average, worked out from critic aggregates, is 8.4 out of 10.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet