Analysis · Splatoon 3

Splatoon 3 polishes the ink shooter for returning fans but adds little new

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Built for players who already love Splatoon 2

Splatoon 3 is built for players who already know what a Charger does and want a better-tuned version of the game they've been playing since Splatoon 2. It's a third-person shooter where two teams of four cover a map in colored ink for three minutes. Every main and sub weapon type from Splatoon 2 returns, along with 15 new ones. For players who want refinement, critics say it delivers. For players who want proof that the series has moved forward, critics were much cooler.

Reviewers split along that same line. The game holds an aggregate of 84/100 across 25 reviews, and the critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 8.4 out of 10. The praise centers on polish and feel. The complaints center on what's missing and on the online service.

Movement is where the refinements pay off

Critics agreed the game feels good to control. Two new moves, the Squid Surge and the Squid Roll, were praised as fun additions that suit the fast pace of competitive matches. Hirun Cryer of GamesRadar+ gave special credit to the Squid Roll. If it's timed as enemy ink hits, it gives a brief window of invincibility, and he argued it rewards players who take time to sharpen their skills. Brian Shea of Game Informer called the movement intuitive.

Smaller changes landed too:

  • The lobby now has a physical practice range in place of a static loading screen.
  • Salmon Run, the co-op mode, is always available instead of being locked to a timed rotation as it was in Splatoon 2.
  • Players can throw Golden Eggs a distance during Salmon Run.
  • New customization options, which Ozzie Mejia of Shacknews liked, though he noted they weren't especially inventive next to other shooters.

Alex Donaldson of VG247 called it the most polished game in the series. The presentation got the same warm response. Wired's Reid McCarter praised the cartoony original characters, Nintendo Life's Alex Olney called Splatsville the series' most expansive hub yet, and IGN staff said the soundtrack's mix of styles "could easily be considered its own genre."

Where it falls short: new ideas and a stable connection

The most common complaint was that too little is new. Olney felt the game lacked a big addition on the scale of Salmon Run in Splatoon 2. Sam Machkovech of Ars Technica called it "disappointing" and pointed out that only five of the 12 maps at launch were new to Splatoon 3, with terrain he found flat. Martin Robinson of Eurogamer felt that even the biggest changes were things you'd expect from any modern online game. The one new mode, the Tableturf Battle card game, struck IGN's Brendan Graeber as unexciting, and Cryer thought it depended too much on luck.

The network problems hurt more in a game built around online play. GameSpot's Steve Watts called in-match disconnections "frequent and unforgiving", and Kotaku's Patricia Hernandez called them "inexcusable". Pramath of GamingBolt found matchmaking waits too long and disliked how some errors sent players back to the queue. Some critics also objected that features outside multiplayer, including the in-game shops, require an internet connection.

In a game whose main draw is four-on-four online matches, connection trouble isn't a side issue. It breaks the thing players came for.

The campaign is more than a tutorial, mostly

The single-player story, Return of the Mammalians, got good reviews. Mejia found its open overworld a welcome change from the more linear hubs of earlier games, and critics described the story as simple but endearing. Several compared its levels to Splatoon 2: Octo Expansion, and some found it harder than the series' earlier story modes. Many credited its challenges with preparing players well for online play.

Not everyone agreed. Destructoid's Chris Carter felt it leaned too heavily on being a straightforward tutorial, though he liked that the levels suit speedrunning. Some reviewers compared the level design to Super Mario Sunshine, while others disliked levels that were too geometric and floated over vague backdrops cut off from the hub world. A further single-player expansion, Side Order, came out on February 22, 2024, as the second half of the paid Expansion Pass.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet