Analysis · Splatoon Raiders

Splatoon Raiders swaps bright paint for grim islands, and critics split on it

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The islands divided critics more than the shooting did

Critics mostly agreed on how Splatoon Raiders plays. They split on how it looks. Christian Donlan of Eurogamer liked the "wonderfully grim" Spirhalite Islands and saw them as a natural next step from the odd, murky style of Salmon Run. Rebekah Valentine of Kotaku saw level themes that felt unconnected to each other and repeated too often to suggest a "lived-in world".

The sharpest note came from IGN's Logan Plant, who otherwise ranked it among the best Switch 2 games so far. Plant found the levels dull to look at and felt their muted colors strayed too far from earlier Splatoon games.

The story caused a smaller split. Plant said it added "plenty of interesting details" to the series' world, and Tashi of Denfaminico Gamer called the back-and-forth between Deep Cut's Shiver, Frye and Big Man "a must-see for fans". Joshua Rivera of The Guardian found the plot too simple to care about.

What the split says about who will enjoy it

Both arguments come down to what you want from Splatoon. If the loud colors and pop styling are the draw, Raiders is a different mood. It takes its look from Salmon Run, the series' darker co-op mode, and its enemies are all Salmonids rather than rival squid kids in bright gear.

If the draw is swimming through your own ink and covering a room in it, critics say Raiders delivers. GameSpot's Steve Watts called it an improvement over the single-player campaigns of earlier entries. Alex Olney of Nintendo Life called the core play excellent but noted it does little to reinvent the formula.

The story works best as a bonus for people who already like Deep Cut. Don't buy it for the plot.

A looter shooter without the grind

Raiders borrows from looter shooters. Defeated Salmonids drop random weapons and experience, and there are over 100 weapons across eleven returning classes, from rollers and brushes to bows. The new idea is gadgets, which replace sub weapons and hang off three ink tanks:

  • Speed Tank: movement, like the Flywire grappling hook.
  • Power Tank: aggression, like the Splatchet's sweeping slash.
  • Tactical Tank: planning, like the linked Bombloons explosives.

Critics liked this more than anything else in the game. Donlan said it lets you try strategies without a "system of torturous intricacy". Jordan Minor of PCMag felt the upgrades avoided "the annoying tedium common in many other looter shooters". Tashi pointed out that gadgets don't use ink, which makes fights less stressful than in past games. The one reservation came from Ozzie Mejia of Shacknews, who found loadout building slightly shallower than in other looter shooters.

Short dungeons that suit co-op

Levels come in five types: linear runs, open islands where you collect power eggs, timed multi-floor dungeons, survival arenas and puzzle gauntlets that teach gadgets. Olney singled out the Spicy mode, which remixes the Salmonids in earlier levels, as a big boost to replay value.

Multiplayer earned praise for staying simple. Progress is shared, so you can play the whole game with others. Rivera thought the bite-sized dungeons suited co-op so well that solo play felt thin by comparison. Pramath of GamingBolt noted the online play ran without major connection trouble.

The weak spot critics flagged in co-op is the random "go help" feature, which Luke Kemp of GamesRadar+ said can send very low-level players to help much stronger ones.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet