Analysis · Splatoon

Splatoon's ink trick won critics over even when its launch felt thin

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Critics agreed it was fun and split on how much the launch should cost it

The widest gap among critics wasn't about whether Splatoon was fun. Hardly anyone doubted that. They split over how much a thin launch should count against it. GamesRadar gave it 3.5 out of 5. It praised the fresh take on the shooter but marked the game down for its lobbies and for content locked behind amiibo figures. Nintendo Life gave it nine out of 10 and called it one of the "most fun" online games available.

IGN landed between them and then changed its mind. Its first score was 7.9, held back by the low number of maps and modes and the lack of voice chat. After several major updates added maps and online modes, IGN reviewed it again and raised the score to 8.6. On Metacritic it scored 81/100 from 88 reviews. The critic average, worked out from those critic aggregates, is 7.9.

Why the ink mattered more than the map count

Fans of the game pointed to one mechanic. Your Inkling shoots ink in its team's color while in humanoid form, then turns into a squid to swim through that ink. As a squid it can climb walls, slip through grates, hide from enemies and refill its ink supply. Enemy ink does the opposite. You walk through it slowly, you can't swim in it, and it wears down your health.

So the map itself keeps changing during a match. In Turf War, the only mode for regular matches, covering ground is the goal, and doing it also charges your special attack. Nintendo Life argued that this made every match play out differently, which helped make up for the small map pool.

Destructoid, which scored it 8.5, said its shortcomings could be forgiven because of "how damn fun it is."

The weapons back this up. Besides gun-like inkers, there are rollers, brushes and ink buckets, each paired with a secondary such as an ink balloon or a sprinkler. The gear you wear also changes your stats, with perks like faster respawns.

What wore on the harsher reviewers

The complaints were about quantity and features, not feel. GameTrailers scored it 8.4 and liked the mechanics and presentation, but said the game felt sparse at launch. Writing for The Guardian, Kate Gray gathered most of the other complaints in one place:

  • Too few multiplayer maps and modes at launch, which made matches feel repetitive.
  • Only two maps per match type at a time, rotating every four hours.
  • Uneven wait times between matches and lopsided team makeups.
  • No voice chat and no private lobbies.

Other critics were unhappy that connection errors cost players points in Ranked Battles. Ranked play rotated through Splat Zones, Tower Control and Rainmaker, with ranks from C− to S+, so a dropped connection mattered more there than in casual matches.

Who the split says will enjoy it

If you've grown tired of gritty, realistic shooters, critics were on your side. Gray contrasted its "90s cartoon aesthetic" with the Call of Duty games and pointed to Jet Set Radio, Super Mario Sunshine and de Blob as influences, along with a catchy soundtrack. The ratings are Everyone 10+ and PEGI 7, so it suits younger players too.

If you play shooters to talk tactics with a regular squad, or to set up custom matches with friends, the criticisms hit you hardest. The missing voice chat and private lobbies were the features reviewers missed most, and the game doesn't offer a workaround.

There's more here than online matches. There's a single-player campaign, local one-on-one matches, and optional gyro aiming on the Wii U GamePad. The GamePad also shows a map you can tap to launch straight to a teammate. IGN's re-review is the clearest sign of where things stood: the harsh launch scores judged the game at its leanest, and the core idea never drew complaints.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet