Star Fox Command drops the rails and adds a turn-based war map
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Every fight is all-range, and a map picks the fights
Star Fox Command rests on one idea. It throws out the on-rails flying that defined most of the series and makes every battle all-range, the free-roaming style Star Fox 64 saved for certain bosses and levels. Then it wraps those battles in a turn-based strategy map. Most of what critics said about this 2006 Nintendo DS game comes back to how well that pairing holds up.
On the map you command up to four ships at once. Your job is to keep enemy ships and missiles away from the Great Fox, the team's mothership. When one of your craft runs into an enemy group, the game cuts to a battle where you destroy a base ship, wipe out every enemy or collect a set number of cores. Then it's back to the map.
The map also feeds the fights. Missiles picked up while exploring, or earned by meeting goals in battle (usually by clearing every enemy), can be fired from the Great Fox. The rails are not entirely gone: some objectives force a classic chase mission.
The stylus flying is what critics agreed on
Free movement in every battle only works if steering feels right, and on this point reviewers mostly agreed. G4's X-Play gave the game 4 out of 5 stars and singled out the stylus control along with the strategy elements. The Associated Press said the game had been built to work well with the DS controls.
IGN scored it 8 out of 10, called it a "surprisingly rich and faithful action game" and said it played much like Star Fox and Star Fox 64. It also gave the game IGN DS's Game of the Month award for August 2006. Game Informer gave it an 8 and praised its solid mechanics. Famitsu scored it 32/40.
The minute-to-minute flying is the part critics praised most consistently.
The strategy layer is where opinion split
The second half of the idea did less well. The Associated Press had mixed feelings about the turn-based sections. Electronic Gaming Monthly went further: the game has its own charm, it said, but it lacks the original gameplay of Star Fox and Star Fox 64 and turns repetitive.
That criticism follows from the design. When every mission sends you from a map to an open arena and back again, and most goals come down to destroying enemies or collecting cores, the loop can start to feel the same. UK site Mansized gave it three out of five stars. The game was nominated in three categories of Nintendo Power's reader-voted awards and won none.
The aggregate scores land in one place. Metacritic has it at 76/100 and GameRankings at 76%. The critic average of 8.0 is computed from three critic scores and is not a score of our own.
A short campaign that branches nine ways
Game Informer criticized the game for being short. The design partly answers that with branching routes. After certain levels you choose where to go next, and each route has its own dialogue and its own planets.
There are 9 endings, and you reach them by playing again and taking different routes. They aren't the same events seen from different angles: the characters end up in genuinely different places depending on the ending. So it's a short game built to be replayed. Whether that makes up for the length depends on how much the core loop appeals to you.
There's no traditional voice acting. Characters speak in the garbled speech of the older games, and a "gibberish generator" lets you record your own voice through the DS microphone and hear it turned into character chatter.
Multiplayer scores on stars, not kills
The all-range idea carries into versus play. Up to six players can join local wireless matches through DS Download Play, and up to three can play over the Nintendo Wi-Fi Connection, which made this the first Star Fox with online multiplayer. Online matches only allow the Arwing II.
You score by collecting stars dropped by destroyed opponents, even ones someone else shot down, so staying near the action matters more than landing the final shot. The mode reworks the multiplayer from Star Fox 64. Online wins moved you up a letter ranking from Z to A. In 2015 the game was re-released on the Wii U's Virtual Console.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Star Fox Command en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q1346365 wikidata.org