Analysis · Star Fox Guard

Star Fox Guard swaps the cockpit for a wall of security cameras

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A Star Fox game with almost no flying

Star Fox Guard came out in April 2016 as a companion to Star Fox Zero. It shipped as a separate disc in the first print edition of that game and was sold later as a download on the Wii U eShop. Nintendo co-developed it with PlatinumGames, and it reads like a test of what else the series could be.

The answer was a tower defense game. You don't pilot a ship. You run security for bases owned by Grippy, the uncle of series regular Slippy Toad, and you fight off waves of robots from a control room. Stephen Totilo of Kotaku said the game had "just about nothing to do with" the aerial shooting fans connect with Star Fox, and he still called it "one of Nintendo's most distinct games in years."

Two screens finally earn their keep

The game is built around the Wii U's split setup. The television shows the feed from every security camera at once, and the Wii U GamePad shows an overhead map of the base. You watch the monitors, spot a threat, then switch to that camera to fire its gun.

That loop asks for a kind of attention most tower defense games don't. You aren't placing turrets and waiting. You're scanning a grid of feeds and choosing which one to take over, then moving on to the next before something reaches the core. The GamePad is doing real work here, not just mirroring the TV.

Two kinds of robot, and the sneaky ones matter more

Enemies come in two classes, and the split is where the design gets interesting:

  • Combat robots attack the base, and you must destroy all of them to clear a stage.
  • Chaos robots go after your cameras instead. They block the view or feed the monitors fake footage.

The Chaos robots turn the game into a contest of trust. A camera you rely on can stop telling you the truth. Jose Otero of IGN singled out the game's "clever enemies" as a highlight, and the camera tampering is the most likely reason.

Where critics thought it came up short

Praise for the ideas came with complaints about almost everything around them. Otero called the campaign "simple" and the graphics "bland." Jonathan Harrington of Nintendo Enthusiast liked the gameplay, variety and online sharing, but he named the lack of humor, the low-budget visuals and the music as weak spots.

Those complaints line up with how the game was released. As a bundled extra, it looks and sounds like one. Reception was mixed, with a critic aggregate of 74/100 from 33 reviews. Other scores in the record run from 73/100 to 7.8/10, so there's little disagreement: good design, modest production.

The extra missions are the reason to keep playing

There's more here than a short campaign. The game has 100 missions, and IGN counted the extra missions as a strength. An editor mode lets you change how enemies behave in a level and share the result online, which Nintendo Enthusiast also praised.

That editor is the best case for the game. Once the campaign's simple structure runs out, player-made enemy patterns can still surprise you. The game is rated Everyone 10+ and PEGI 7, so it suits younger players who can handle watching several screens at once.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet