Analysis · Star Fox

Star Fox rebuilds the 1997 classic for players who missed it the first time

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for newcomers first, and veterans second

Star Fox is a remake of Star Fox 64 (1997) for the Nintendo Switch 2. It keeps the original's levels, story and controls, and adds a new art style and longer cutscenes. The player it suits best is someone who never played the 1997 game, or someone who played it once long ago and wants it back without the rough edges.

For that player, critics were close to unanimous. NintendoLife's Jim Norman called it "a sublime remaster," GamesRadar+ called it "the definitive way to play Star Fox 64," and Retro Gamer's Darran Jones rated it above the Nintendo 64 original. The critic average, which is computed from critic aggregates, is 8.2 out of 10, and 87% of critics recommended it.

The same critics also warned the other group. Norman said players who have finished the original "hundreds of times" won't find surprises here, and Jones's only real complaint was the lack of anything new, such as a fresh level.

Where it delivers: a campaign you replay by choice

The structure that made the 1997 game last is still here. You fly the Arwing along a set path through planets in the Lylat System, shooting enemies with lasers and bombs and using a barrel roll to deflect fire. Each level can end in different ways, and meeting certain conditions opens branching paths to other planets. That makes one run short but sends players back for more.

  • Three difficulties. On Normal and Hard, shields and boost start limited and grow as you collect gold and silver rings.
  • Optional tasks in each level give rewards for players chasing every route.
  • Challenge Mode lets you replay single levels with different objectives.
  • New cutscenes between levels fill in the characters and the world.

Eurogamer's Chris Schilling summed up the appeal and the limit together, calling it "a triumph of nostalgia over innovation." Giant Bomb's Mike Minotti described it as a fairly faithful remake of the series' best entry.

Co-op is the biggest new idea

The most interesting addition is two-player co-op. One player flies with standard controls while the other aims and fires using the Joy-Con 2's mouse controls, and this works in both the campaign and Challenge Mode. Pocket Tactics' Kayleigh Partleton called the game "a blast" in solo and co-op alike.

The mouse aiming also works in single-player, and the game supports the Nintendo 64 Wireless Controller for anyone who wants the old feel. GameShare lets multiplayer run across several Switch 2 consoles and original Switch models, locally or online, which makes it easier to bring a friend in without a second copy.

Where it falls short: length, extras and price

The complaints cluster in one place: there isn't much beyond the campaign. TechRadar's Daishell Wood called it "a solid remake of an excellent game" but said the short campaign and "threadbare" multiplayer didn't justify the launch price. IGN's Jada Griffin felt Challenge Mode and the revamped multiplayer didn't go far enough. GameSpot's Steve Watts called it a "bare-bones" refresh and pointed out that the original is already playable through Nintendo Switch Online.

The battle mode splits players into the Star Fox and Star Wolf squads across maps with their own rules, and it can be played against computer opponents. Critics didn't treat it as a reason to buy.

This is the fifth game to tell the same Star Fox 64 story, after the original, Star Fox 64 3D and Star Fox Zero.

That repetition was a sore point before launch, along with the more realistic character redesigns, which divided fans when the game was revealed.

Why the critics still came away hopeful

Many reviewers ended up talking about the future. Shacknews' Asif Khan said it pointed to a promising future for Velan Studios and the series. Destructoid's Scott Duwe called it "a worthwhile ride" but was more curious about what comes next. Game Informer's Kyle Hilliard didn't want another Star Fox 64 remake and still had "a great, nostalgic time."

Read it as a well-made reset, not a new chapter. If you buy it, you're paying for the best version of a 1997 classic plus co-op, not for new missions.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet