Star Fox Zero remakes Star Fox 64 around controls many critics fought
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Made for players who still know Star Fox 64 by heart
Star Fox Zero is a reimagining of Star Fox 64, developed by Nintendo and PlatinumGames and released on the Wii U in April 2016. It's aimed at players who loved that game's branching routes, boss fights and radio chatter and want them again with a few new tricks. Fox flies with Falco, Peppy and Slippy once more, and Star Wolf returns to harass them.
The map mixes old and new. Corneria, Zoness, Titania, Fichina and Fortuna come back, and Sector Alpha, Area 3, Sector Beta, Sector Gamma and Sector Omega are new. Levels alternate between on-rails stretches, where the path is set for you, and All-Range Mode, which lets you fly freely inside a closed-off arena.
For that player, the familiarity is the point. Nintendo Life's Damien McFerran called it "reassuringly familiar" and judged it on par with the N64 game it borrows from. Others wanted more. EGM's Ray Carsillo was disappointed that Nintendo reworked an older game rather than making a new one, and Giant Bomb's Dan Ryckert called it a relic of 2002.
The controls take two screens and real patience
This is where the game loses people. You steer with the left stick and aim by tilting the Wii U GamePad, which shows a cockpit view on its own screen. The minus button swaps the TV and GamePad views at any time. You can't switch to a stick-only setup.
Critics disagreed on whether the effort pays off:
- IGN's Jose Otero liked the game but called the controls awkward.
- McFerran said players need patience before the controls click, and compared the adjustment to Splatoon.
- GameSpot's Peter Brown objected mainly to switching his attention back and forth between the TV and the GamePad.
- GamesRadar's David Roberts argued the whole design was built around the GamePad's features whether they made sense or not.
- Polygon's Arthur Gies gave no score because the controls made the game too miserable to finish.
If aiming by tilting a controller while glancing between two screens sounds tiring, the reviews give no sign that it gets easier for everyone.
Where it delivers: levels, bosses and the second run
Critics who got past the controls found a well-made shooter underneath. Otero praised the levels and bosses. Brown found his second run more enjoyable than his first and singled out the branching paths and level design. Like Star Fox 64, the game is built for replaying.
There's no lives system. If your ship is destroyed or you miss a key objective, the mission fails. Collect three gold rings and you can restart from the last checkpoint phase instead of the start of the level. Earning enough gold medals unlocks two extra ships: the Retro Arwing, based on the original SNES model, and the faster but more fragile Black Arwing. Scanning the Fox or Falco Amiibo unlocks them right away.
The box also includes Star Fox Guard, a standalone tower defense game.
The new vehicles split opinion, and the campaign is short
The new ideas come mostly from transforming vehicles. The Arwing can become the Walker, a two-legged mode for platforms and tight spaces. The Landmaster tank can turn into the Gravmaster for short flights. The new Gyrowing is a hovering drone that lowers a small robot called Direct-i to hack computers and drop explosive cubes on enemies.
These missions are where Zero differs most from earlier games, and that cut both ways. Shacknews' Steve Watts felt they ultimately pulled attention away from the core Arwing flying. Reviewers also kept returning to the short campaign, which matters more when much of it is a remake.
Scores landed in the middle. The aggregate for 86 reviews was 69/100, a mixed reception. The critic average of 7.7 is calculated from three critic scores and is not a score of our own.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Star Fox Zero en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q17168217 wikidata.org