Star Ocean's fifth entry keeps the combat and loses the cutscenes
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The fifth Star Ocean kept the fights and dropped the cinema
Star Ocean: Integrity and Faithlessness is the fifth major installment in the Star Ocean series and follows Star Ocean: The Last Hope. tri-Ace developed it and Square Enix published it. It came out on PlayStation 4 in Japan on March 31, 2016, and a PlayStation 3 version followed there on April 28. It reached North America on June 28 and Europe on July 1.
Critics put it squarely in the middle. Metacritic called its reviews "mixed or average", with platform scores of 57/100 and a 60/100 drawn from 54 reviews. The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 5.9 out of 10.
In short, the combat that defines the series survived and, by most accounts, improved. The way the story is told changed, and most reviewers couldn't forgive it.
What carried over from earlier games
Series fans will recognize most of the structure. Battles run in real time. You control one party member at a time and can switch between them whenever you like. Item creation is back. So is the private actions system, which tracks which party members interact during the story and changes where the story goes based on those moments.
The biggest change to combat is scale, since up to seven party members fight at once. Destructoid found the combat smooth and manageable even with all seven in play, and GamesRadar praised its fast, arcade-like pace. The developers described the enemy AI as "very complex", and players can adjust how smart enemies are, within limits.
The praise had a catch. GamesRadar noted that your party members have no spatial awareness, which makes it hard to plan anything beyond pressing forward.
Why critics missed the cutscenes
The biggest change is in how the story is told. There are no traditional cutscenes. Story scenes play out in the game world with an adjustable camera, and they were designed to be interactive and to lead straight back into play. Reviewers mostly saw this as a loss:
- IGN said the acting lost emotional impact without cutscenes.
- Destructoid pointed to dialogue you can't skip and a camera that sometimes missed the characters' facial reactions.
- Game Informer described long conversations spent staring at "the backs of your party members' heads".
- GamesRadar felt the low production values meant characters talked about events, like space battles, instead of showing them.
Polygon named the related letdown. A space opera leads players to expect long stretches in space, and this one doesn't deliver them. For a series built on that premise, Polygon called it the most frustrating part of the game.
A cast that split critics and a world that wears thin
Critics genuinely disagreed about the characters. IGN and GamesRadar liked the cast. Game Informer called the characters cliché and underdeveloped. GameSpot went after the writing itself, faulting the poor dialogue and the lack of any clear reason for the heroes to team up.
The presentation is uneven in other ways too. IGN praised the musical score but found the graphics swung from very high quality to something closer to Minecraft. GameSpot added that the same enemies keep reappearing in the same places, which makes crossing the large world a slog.
The battle system is the reason to play. The space adventure is the reason most critics came away disappointed.
If you value fast party combat and the private actions system most, there's enough here to justify a discounted copy. If you want a cinematic science fiction story, critics consistently said this isn't it.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Star Ocean: Integrity and Faithlessness en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q19800947 wikidata.org