Analysis · Star Trek Online

Star Trek Online's ship combat carries a game critics still can't agree on

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Critics have called it both the worst and the best Star Trek game

In 2016, Den of Geek put Star Trek Online on its list of the worst Star Trek games. That same year, Tom's Guide put it in its top ten. PC Gamer ranked it among the best in 2017, and in 2020 Screen Rant went further, calling it the best Star Trek game and saying the franchise is "perfectly suited" to being an online role-playing game.

The aggregate scores don't settle it. Critics averaged 66/100 across 34 reviews, and the critic average, worked out from those critic aggregates, is 6.8 out of 10. A smaller 2016 tally of seven reviews came in at 68/100 on one measure and 29% on another. With results that far apart, people are judging different things, not settling on a middle score.

Two games that don't quite fit together

Each player captains a ship. In space, you run its engineering, tactical and science systems with keyboard and mouse or an on-screen console, and you win by placing the ship so your shields take hits well. On the ground, you beam down with an away team for fast run-and-gun fights where flanking and finding weak points matter.

The critics who disliked it mostly disliked one half. GameSpot found the space combat entertaining and the rest "bland and shallow". IGN described the game as feeling like "two games" that didn't mesh, while still calling it "quite a gorgeous game".

Read together, those reviews point the same way. The slower, positional ship battles are why people stay. The ground missions are the part you sit through to get back to the ship. If space combat is what pulls you in, that criticism matters less to you.

Repetition is the complaint critics agreed on

Critics who disagreed on almost everything else still agreed that the missions repeat. IGN called much of the gameplay repetitive. MMOify reviewed it favorably but still flagged repetitive quests and "poor voice acting". PC Gamer, on the other hand, pointed out that the game includes original voice work by actors from the live-action series, which matters a lot to fans of the show.

A lot of the game runs on timers:

  • Crafting means picking a project and letting duty officers (junior crew) finish it after a set time. You never do the work by hand.
  • Duty officer assignments send crew away on jobs, and they're unavailable until those jobs finish.
  • Admiralty missions, open to characters at level 52 and up, send ships you own or used to own on timed missions that come back as a success or a failure.

This system suits short sessions where you check in, set things running and log off. It won't satisfy players who want crafting to be a game of its own.

What the split says about who will like it

The best reviews tend to judge it as a Star Trek game, and the harshest judge it as an online role-playing game. It is set in the 25th century, 30 years after Star Trek: Nemesis, and it was the first online role-playing game in the franchise. Screen Rant's praise is about how well Trek suits the format, not about polish.

That makes the audience fairly clear. Fans who want their own ship and crew in that setting will forgive repetitive ground missions. Players with no ties to the franchise will see mostly the faults GameSpot and IGN described.

It's also cheaper to try than it was at launch, when it needed a purchase and a monthly fee. Free-to-play opened on January 17, 2012, without full access to every item. It launched on Microsoft Windows in February 2010 and came to PlayStation 4 and Xbox One in September 2016. A Mac version came out in March 2014, but support ended in February 2016.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet