Analysis · Star Wars Battlefront II

Star Wars Battlefront II fixed its multiplayer but never its thin campaign

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Good blasters, and starfighters with more variety

Every match starts on foot or in a cockpit. On the ground you pick one of four soldier classes: Assault, Heavy, Officer or Specialist. You can play in first or third person. Each faction's troopers handle the same way and only look different, so a clone trooper and a battle droid play alike. Starfighters have more variety. The Fighter, Interceptor and Bomber classes each have their own abilities, though the Resistance and the First Order don't get a Bomber. Criterion Games built the starfighter mechanics.

The shooting got the most consistent praise. IGN's Tom Marks said the game has "great feeling blasters," and EGM's Nick Plessas singled out its combat, balancing and variety.

Ground battles also have a reward loop. Kills and map objectives earn battle points, which you can trade for Reinforcement classes: the Enforcer, Aerial and Infiltrator soldiers, or the Speeder and Armor vehicles. On some Galactic Assault maps you can also call in Artillery, such as the Separatist MTT on Naboo and Kashyyyk. Playing the objective is how you earn the bigger units.

Three eras, 15 launch maps and eight more added later

The game covers three wars: the Republic against the Separatists in the Clone Wars, the Rebels against the Empire in the Galactic Civil War, and the Resistance against the First Order. It launched with 15 locations, including Kamino, Hoth, Endor, Mos Eisley, Takodana and Starkiller Base, plus space-only maps over Ryloth, Fondor and the Unknown Regions.

Eight more maps came later:

  • Crait, Jabba's Palace, Kessel and Geonosis
  • Felucia, Ajan Kloss and Scarif
  • D'Qar, a space-only map

Some ground maps are only available in certain modes, so not every map shows up in every playlist. The game also has single-player, co-op and multiplayer modes.

Progression is where the launch went wrong

Star Cards are the main form of progression. Each class level gives you a Skill Point, which you can spend on a card or an upgrade. A class can carry up to three cards, and they raise stats such as health regeneration or damage, or swap one ability for another. New weapons come from milestones, and attachments change stats like range and fire rate.

At launch, critics tied that system to loot crates and didn't like what they saw. Game Revolution criticized the microtransactions, the loot box progression and the locked heroes. Game Informer's Andrew Reiner gave it 6.5 and said the whole experience was "brought down by microtransactions." GamesRadar+ liked the multiplayer but called the progression "overly complicated."

The awards that year followed the same split. IGN nominated the game for Best Shooter and Best Multiplayer. Giant Bomb made it a runner-up for Most Disappointing Game, and Game Informer named it the Biggest Disappointment in its shooter awards. EA said the game sold 9 million copies by December 2017, short of its 10 million target, and blamed the loot crate controversy.

A beautiful campaign that plays it safe

Motive Studio wrote the single-player story. It follows Iden Versio, commander of an Imperial special ops unit called Inferno Squad. It's set in the last year of the Galactic Civil War, between Return of the Jedi and The Force Awakens, leading up to the Battle of Jakku.

Critics liked how the campaign looked, but not much else. Andy Hartup at GamesRadar+ called it "lavish, beautiful" but said it lacked substance and subtlety. Game Revolution thought it started strong and got weaker as it went. Even IGN's much warmer 2019 re-review called the story "overly safe, short, and disappointing." The look and sound were never in question: Game Informer gave the game its Best Graphics and Best Audio awards, and IGN nominated it for Best Graphics.

Why the score undersells the multiplayer

Most critic scores are from launch, and they average out to "mixed or average" on Metacritic. The critic average of 6.6, worked out from those critic aggregates, reflects the same thing. Those launch scores mostly judged the progression system, not the shooting.

In 2019, IGN's David Jagneaux raised the score to 8.8 and wrote that EA and DICE had "redeemed this gorgeous shooter."

Jagneaux credited the improvement to the multiplayer and said the campaign was unchanged. The published reviews end at that 2019 look, so they can't tell you how full the servers are today. If you're buying it for the online battles, check that first.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet