Analysis · Starbound

Starbound kept its procedural sandbox and spent years adding a story

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The game Chucklefish made before Wargroove

Starbound is Chucklefish's 2016 action-adventure game, and the studio both developed and published it. It came before Chucklefish's turn-based strategy games, Wargroove in 2019 and Wargroove 2 in 2023, and it's a very different kind of game: an open sandbox set in space, not a tactics game on a grid.

People were waiting for it long before release. Indie Game Magazine named it the most anticipated game of 2013. It left early access in July 2016 on Windows, OS X and Linux, and by December 2016 it had sold over 2.5 million copies. It came to Xbox Game Pass on Windows in December 2020, then to Xbox One and Xbox Series X/S in October 2024.

What stayed the same: a 2D universe built by procedure

The core of the game hasn't changed. It takes place in a two-dimensional universe where planets, enemies and items are procedurally generated, so no two places are laid out the same way. The game asks you to explore that universe, fight what lives there, collect weapons and armor, reshape the ground under your feet, and visit towns and villages run by various intelligent species.

Two design choices make it more than a loot run:

  • Your class is your clothing. There's no class picked from a menu. What you wear decides what you are, so changing your role means changing your gear.
  • There's a quieter, homesteading side. You can farm and sell crops, put up buildings, and charge rent to the NPC tenants who move in.

Critics praised this side of the game most. IGN singled out its crafting, exploration and combat, and compared it to Terraria. Christopher Livingston of PC Gamer called it a charming space sandbox that would keep players busy for hours. Kotaku's Nathan Grayson praised the exploration and said the universe was "strange and unpredictable" enough that players wouldn't tire of it.

What changed: a story, then mechs, then an ending

Most of the changes arrived as numbered updates after release, and each one added structure on top of the sandbox.

  1. Update 1.0 added a story. Each chapter works the same way: explore the sandbox to scan a set of items, such as human items, then clear a story dungeon and fight a boss.
  2. Update 1.3, first released as an unstable build, added modular mechs. You fit them with guns, shields or drills and choose a body that sets their energy and health. They're mostly used for exploring outer space areas, such as asteroid fields and ships.
  3. Update 1.4 moved those mechs into the main game and added a bounty hunter questline that brings the story to a close. As of 2019 it was the final content update.

The mechs and the bounty questline give the game a real ending. The story's scan-then-dungeon pattern is the weaker addition: it keeps you exploring, but repeating the same steps every chapter makes the plot feel like a checklist laid over the sandbox.

Critics agreed, and the scores held

Critics didn't split on Starbound. Metacritic reported favorable reviews, with the PC version at 81 out of 100 from 21 reviews. The Windows and Xbox versions each scored 88 out of 100, but those scores come from only six reviews apiece, so give them less weight. Another aggregate site listed 85 out of 100 from 16 reviews in 2018 and 82% from 19 reviews in 2025, so critics' view has barely moved in seven years.

The critic average of 8.5 out of 10 is calculated from those critic aggregates. It is not a separate grade. The steady numbers suggest the sandbox, not the later story, is what keeps the game rated well.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet