Starhawk's online battles carry a story mode critics found thin
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The split between a 9.0 and a 7.5
Starhawk's critic scores sit in a fairly narrow band, but the two big outlets landed far enough apart to show where the argument was. IGN gave it a 9.0/10. Game Informer gave it a 7.50/10. Metacritic puts it at 77, which it labels generally favorable, and the critic average of 7.7, worked out from those critic aggregates, sits in the same place.
The disagreement wasn't really about whether the shooting works. It was about how much weight to give each half of the game. Reviewers who cared most about the online mode came away happy, with some calling it the "best multiplayer on the PS3." The reviewers who held back pointed to a weak story and characters they found uninteresting. Your view of Starhawk will depend on which half you'd actually spend your time in.
Building in the middle of a firefight
Starhawk is a third-person shooter set in science fiction, made by LightBox Interactive and published by Sony for the PlayStation 3. It's the spiritual successor to 2007's Warhawk, and it plays much like it. Its biggest addition is a system called Build and Battle.
Build and Battle lets players put up structures such as bunkers, defenses and armories during a fight. That adds a bit of real-time strategy to a game that is still a shooter at heart. A well-placed wall or supply point can change how a fight goes, which gives a team something to plan around beyond aim.
A few other systems give it its own feel:
- Hawks: flying mechs that add an air layer to battles.
- Drop-in respawns: you come back in a landing craft that you can steer a short way, so you choose where you land.
- Large matches: online battles of up to 32 players, 16 per side, as in Warhawk.
- Co-op: a mode where players hold out together, similar in idea to Horde Mode in the Gears of War series.
Why the campaign kept the score down
The single-player story is the newest piece of Starhawk. Warhawk was meant to have one too, but it was cut before that game shipped. Here it finally made it in, and critics mostly weren't impressed.
The complaints were specific: a weak story and characters that didn't hold interest. Nobody singled out the campaign as broken. It just didn't match the quality of the online game it was built around. For a series coming back with its first real story mode, that's a letdown, and it explains why the scores stopped short of the top.
Starhawk's best parts need other players. Its weakest part is the one you play alone.
Who gets the most out of it
The split in the reviews works almost like a buyer's guide. If your idea of a good shooter night is a crowded match where the team that builds smartest wins, Starhawk is aimed right at you. The 16-versus-16 battles, the Hawks and the mid-fight building are the parts critics rated highest, and they're the reason for the 9.0 at the top of its range.
Players who enjoy holding out together will also find something in the co-op mode, since it uses the same building ideas against waves of enemies.
If you want a shooter for its plot, cast and solo campaign, the 7.50 is the more useful number. The campaign is there and it works as a way to learn the systems, but critics didn't think it could carry the game on its own. Starhawk is rated Teen and PEGI 16.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Starhawk (2012 video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q961171 wikidata.org