State of Decay 2 keeps its predecessor's shape and builds it around co-op
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A sequel that stays close to home
State of Decay 2 is Undead Labs' follow-up to State of Decay. Xbox Game Studios published it for Windows and Xbox One on May 22, 2018. It keeps the first game's basic idea. You lead a small community through a zombie outbreak, scavenge for supplies in an open world and keep everyone alive from one day to the next.
Much carries over. The game is played from a third-person view and is mostly about scavenging. As in the first game, special zombies outclass the regular ones in a one-on-one fight: animal-like Ferals and tank-like Juggernauts. The sequel's main pitches are co-op for up to three other players and a choice of several locations for your base.
The base is where most of the game happens
Most of your decisions are about the base. You add watchtowers, gardens, sleeping quarters, kitchens, workshops and medical bays. You also juggle five resources: food, medicine, ammo, construction materials and fuel. You get them by scavenging or by trading with survivors outside your group. You can also help those survivors or recruit them.
Each survivor has fixed traits, some helpful and some not, such as tiring out quickly. They also have morale that shifts after close calls, deaths and hard wins. A flawed survivor can still earn a hero bonus if their standing in the community rises. That's a smart way to make weak recruits worth keeping.
Critics weren't convinced it adds up to much. GameSpot's Alessandro Barbosa took issue with how little depth the survival systems have. IGN's Dan Stapleton made the same complaint about the "board-game-style" management. The systems are wide, with many facilities and stats to track, but critics found few interesting choices inside them.
Critics liked the fights and the bugs hurt
Combat drew the most consistent praise. IGN called it "simple but satisfying", and Barbosa also enjoyed it. The design gives you real choices. Zombies respawn without end unless you set up an outpost nearby. They're drawn to noise and can sprint nearly as fast as you. You can fight, sneak past or distract them with firecrackers. Cars help you get around, but they take damage from obstacles and from running over zombies, so you need toolkits to keep them going.
Stapleton also singled out the variety of zombies and the constant fear that a survivor could die permanently. That risk is what makes each supply run feel tense.
Both critics named in the reception, at GameSpot and IGN, complained about bugs.
Barbosa also felt the routine of survival could be dull, calling it close to the "mundane reality" of an actual apocalypse. For a game about chores, that complaint matters.
Middling scores and a large player count
On Metacritic the game sits at "mixed or average." The aggregate scores tell the same story: 69/100 from 31 reviews of both the Xbox One and Windows versions, 67/100 from 12 reviews and 69/100 from 129. The harshest figure is a 31% rating from 130 reviews, dated May 2023. The individual reviews range from GameSpot's 5/10 to IGN's 7.5/10. The critic average, calculated from those critic aggregates, is 6.8 out of 10.
Players were kinder than the scores. Microsoft announced more than 10 million players by August 2021. The game was also nominated for Best Co-Operative Game and Xbox Game of the Year at the 2018 Golden Joystick Awards. Its Daybreak add-on was nominated for Best Add-on/DLC at Gamescom 2018. Those co-op and add-on nominations suggest playing with friends is where this sequel works best.
Sources
- Wikipedia: State of Decay 2 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q24807151 wikidata.org