Analysis · Stray

Stray's cat carries the game, even when its puzzles forget it's a cat

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Being a cat is the whole idea, and it mostly works

Stray rests on one premise: you are a stray cat who has fallen into a walled city of robots and is trying to get back to the surface. Rock Paper Shotgun's Katharine Castle put the cat at "at least 50% of the appeal," and the wider critical response backs her up. Reviewers praised how closely the game copies real cat behavior, from the animation to how easy it is to leap, climb and squeeze through the world.

The small, pointless things are part of the appeal. The cat can sleep, meow and rub against robots, and most of them react. It can claw at objects, ride in buckets, knock over paint cans and work a vending machine. None of that is required, which is why it lands. The Guardian's Keza MacDonald called the game "an excellent example of how a change of perspective" can freshen a setting players have grown used to.

The weak spots are mechanical. Some critics ran into awkward controls and camera angles now and then. PCMag's Gabriel Zamora was disappointed by how little choice the platforming allows.

A city that makes more sense at knee height

Critics were close to unanimous on the art, and they singled out the lighting in particular. The Washington Post's Alyse Stanley called the game "a master class in environmental story telling and level design," praising how quietly it points you where to go. Wired's Will Bedingfield credited its take on Kowloon Walled City, with its cramped buildings, makeshift rooms and neon nightlife.

The cat premise is what makes that density pay off. A city of stacked rooms and ledges is a playground for something that climbs, and GamesRadar+'s Sam Loveridge called it "a stunning place to just exist in." The score helps: Kotaku's Ari Notis called it "deliciously jazzy," and Ars Technica's Sam Machkovech ranked it among the year's best.

Not everyone bought the setting. The A.V. Club's William Hughes saw a "Lego stack of ready-made video game tropes," Kotaku's Sisi Jiang read it as a troubling case of techno-orientalism, and VentureBeat's Rachel Kaser found the Zurk-infested levels the weakest looking.

The puzzles forget they were written for a cat

This is where the central idea wears thinnest. You move the story forward by finding objects for robots and solving puzzles that mostly involve shifting obstacles. B-12, the drone companion, translates, stores items, lights dark spaces and hacks machines. Electronic Gaming Monthly's Josh Harmon called that loop "distinctly uncatlike," and it's a fair hit: for long stretches the cat works as a courier with fur.

Difficulty is low. Jeuxvideo.com's Pauline Leclercq found the puzzles generally easy, though better in the second half, while The A.V. Club's Hughes found them repetitive over time. On the other side, GameSpot's Alessandro Barbosa praised the pacing between sequences, and VG247's Kelsey Raynor expected repetition but found the game stayed enjoyable.

Running from Zurks fits the cat better than fighting them

Stray has two kinds of threat. Zurks are mutated bacteria that swarm and devour the cat. Sentinels are security drones that shoot on sight, and the game marks their sight lines with glowing lights. For part of the game, B-12 carries a Defluxor that destroys Zurks but overheats after a short burst.

Critics split cleanly. Harmon at EGM thought the Zurk sequences felt "more authentically cat," and The Escapist's Damien Lawardorn rated them among the most compelling chapters. PC Gamer's Jon Bailes described one fight as "repeated backpedalling and shooting," and IGN's Tom Marks and The Verge's Andrew Webster both found the swarms could get frustrating. Game Informer's Blake Hester called them monotonous but appreciated how rarely they come up. Stealth drew the same split, from Bailes enjoying it to Vice's Renata Price rating it "from fine to frustrating."

Measured against the premise, the chases fit and the weapon doesn't. A cat running for its life makes sense. A cat backing up while its drone fires is where the idea slips.

A small hero carrying a bigger story

Several reviewers were surprised that a game about a cat had this much to say. The Verge's Webster picked out "themes ranging from wealth inequality to environmental disaster" and called the ending tragic and beautiful. Polygon's Alexis Ong tied the game to Hong Kong's democracy movement and the 2019–2020 protests, pointing to its working title, HK Project. PCGamesN's Nat Smith called the robots "whimsical and strikingly human."

The cat can't speak, so B-12 translates and the robots carry the emotion, and the hero never stops being a cat. Not everyone found the ideas deep: NME's Jordan Oloman said the game lacked the intelligence and subtlety of Nier: Automata, and Hester called its themes simple but effective.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet