Super Mario 3D World turns 3D Land's tidy courses into a four-player romp
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A handheld formula rebuilt for the living room
Super Mario 3D World is the sixth original 3D platform game in the Super Mario series and a direct sequel to Super Mario 3D Land (2011). That lineage explains almost everything about it. It isn't an open sandbox like the series' earlier 3D games. It keeps 3D Land's hybrid: you move freely in three dimensions, but inside a course with a timer that ends at a flagpole, the way the 2D side-scrollers always did.
The big change is who's playing. Up to four people can run the same level at once, sharing a pool of lives. They pick from Mario, Luigi, Princess Peach, Toad and an unlockable Rosalina. The characters aren't just skins:
- Mario is the balanced default.
- Luigi jumps higher and falls slower, with less traction.
- Peach can float briefly but runs slowly.
- Toad is the fastest runner and the weakest jumper.
- Rosalina brings the spin attack from the Super Mario Galaxy games but runs slowest of all.
Levels hang off a world map with hidden corners. Each one hides three Green Stars, which gate later stages, so collecting matters as much as reaching the flag.
The cat suit earned its place on the box
The returning items are familiar: the Fire Flower, Super Leaf, Mega Mushroom, Propeller Box and Boomerang Flower. The new ones do more to change how levels are built. The Super Bell's Cat Suit lets a character run faster, pounce and climb walls. That last ability changes where a level can hide things. Destructoid's Chris Carter said the suit "opens up doors" the series hadn't had before.
The Double Cherry clones your character, and every extra cherry adds another copy. Carter singled it out as a technical feat. There's also a lot of smaller stuff: Cannon Boxes that fire at enemies, Light Blocks that beat ghosts, a Goomba mask for blending in, a Skating Shoe and a swimming dinosaur called Plessie. Eurogamer's Christian Donlan called the result "an endless freewheeling treat" built around finding new situations to drop Mario into.
Not everyone loved the cast. Edge argued that Mario is the most fun to play because the others' abilities "aren't anything special." That's a fair warning if you were hoping each character would open a different route.
Co-op is the headline, and the camera pays for it
Players can pick each other up and throw each other, which turns co-op into friendly sabotage. IGN's Jose Otero praised the "genuinely funny and memorable co-op," and GamesRadar's Henry Gilbert said the multiplayer had improved. Edge went further and called it the Wii U's best game to date.
The same reviewers named the cost. Otero's only complaint was that the camera gets in the way with four players on screen. GameTrailers also noted camera problems, along with some odd control choices. Four people sharing one fixed view of a 3D space is a hard problem, and the game doesn't fully solve it.
Plan on two players for the cleanest experience. Four is the funniest and also the most likely to end in someone falling off the edge.
Where the praise ran out
Kotaku's Luke Plunkett summed up the main reservation: a terrific game, "just not a very good Wii U game." The GamePad features are mostly small extras: rubbing the touchscreen or blowing into the microphone to reveal blocks or slow enemies, plus Off-TV Play. The game also works with the Wii Remote, Classic Controller and Wii U Pro Controller, so the tablet is easy to ignore.
Carter called the boss fights the design's "only downfall." The Escapist's Bob Chipman gave four out of five stars and told readers not to expect their minds to be blown. Some features have also aged out: the hidden collectibles in each main level were made for posts on Miiverse, and that online community is now defunct.
What stayed strong is the level design. It's what most critics praised, and it's why the game was re-released on Nintendo Switch in February 2021 as Super Mario 3D World + Bowser's Fury. Its Captain Toad puzzle stages also grew into their own spin-off.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Super Mario 3D World en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q13426947 wikidata.org