Analysis · Super Mario 64

Super Mario 64 still sets the bar for 3D movement, even with its camera

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Two reputations that are both true

GamePro called Super Mario 64 "the most visually impressive game of all time," and Electronic Gaming Monthly later ranked it the fourth best console game ever made. In a 2007 re-review, Game Informer said that by present-day standards its camera "would almost be considered broken." Both views hold up, and the space between them explains the game.

The scores lean hard toward the first view. Metacritic averages 94 out of 100 across 13 reviews, and GameRankings put it at 96%. The critic average of 9.4 is computed from those critic aggregates. Electronic Gaming Monthly named it Game of the Year, and the 1997 Computer Game Developers Conference gave it Spotlight Awards for Best Console Game and Best Game of 1996.

Mario's moves carry the whole game

This was the first Super Mario game in 3D, and the bigger set of moves is what made the jump work. Using the analog stick and buttons, Mario can run, crouch, crawl, climb, swim, kick, grab objects and punch. Combining a jump with other actions gives him the double and triple jumps, the long jump, the backflip and the wall jump.

Computer and Video Games editor Paul Davies called the control scheme intuitive and versatile. Electronic Gaming Monthly praised the courses for their size and challenge, and that mix only works because Mario has so many ways to get around.

Classic power-ups like the Super Mushroom are gone. In their place:

  • Health: a pie of eight segments, refilled by yellow, red and blue coins, spinning hearts, or jumping into water.
  • Cap power-ups: the Wing Cap for flight, the Metal Cap for immunity and walking underwater, and the Vanish Cap for passing through some obstacles. Each one becomes available after you find its colored switch in a secret area.
  • Koopa shells: left behind after a stomp, they let Mario surf over water, lava and quicksand.

A castle of paintings built for poking around

The setup is simple. Bowser kidnaps Princess Peach and hides the castle's Power Stars inside magical paintings. Each star you collect opens more of the castle, so finding new areas becomes the reward for exploring.

Critics returned to that freedom again and again. Maximum named the sense of freedom and the replay value as the game's strongest points. Nintendo Life's Corbie Dillard called its variety the game's "greatest genius," and GameFan's E. Storm was won over by the water levels. N64 Magazine likened it to an enormous playground but felt the many hints and tips took some of the edge off exploring. Victor Lucas of EP Daily agreed, telling players to "skip all the sign posts." That's sound advice: the courses reward finding things out for yourself.

The visuals got almost as much attention. Hyper's Nino Alegeropoulos called it the best-looking console game to date and credited its high resolution and frame rate. Chris Hudak of VideoGameSpot liked graphics that stayed "clean yet simple" without hiding the details of the world.

The camera is where critics split

The camera is a Lakitu filming Mario, and you can adjust it and switch between first-person and third-person views. Even so, it drew the sharpest complaints the game received:

  • Next Generation found the game less accessible than earlier Mario games because the camera moved erratically and often lacked a good angle.
  • Nebojsa Radakovic of GameRevolution and Doug Perry of IGN both said it sometimes got blocked by objects or passed through them.
  • Dan Hsu, Shawn Smith and Crispin Boyer of Electronic Gaming Monthly each took half a point off their scores over it.
  • Nintendo Power noted the learning curve.

Not everyone agreed. Corbie Dillard said the camera had no problems and helped with complex environments, and another magazine's reviewers counted very few bad angles. Paul Davies admitted it was sometimes hard to position but called it "one hiccup" in a "revolutionary" game.

So many outlets raised the same specific faults that it's best to plan on adjusting the camera yourself, often, and especially on narrow ledges.

The complaints get stronger with time: Game Informer's harshest line came in 2007, not 1996. If you're used to modern 3D games, this is the part that will feel old.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet